PequodPod
The podcast on the wonder-world of Herman Melville. We're currently reading Moby-Dick and talking about each chapter. We also enjoy and discuss Melville's other works such as Typee, Omoo, Mardi, Redburn, Whitejacket, Pierre, Bartleby, Benito Cereno, The Confidence-Man, Billy Budd, and more!
Support the show: www.patreon.com/PequodPod
PequodPod
Episode 12: Nightgown
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Welcome to PequodPod! The podcast on the wonder-world of Herman Melville.
Are you a summer person or a winter person? More importantly, do you make out with your eyes open? The ’Quod Squad asks these and other essential questions while discussing “Nightgown,” a chapter curiously devoid of physical but perhaps not metaphorical nightgowns. Cold-weather coziness abounds, alongside prolepsis and analepsis, rhymes and negatives, our first drops of whale oil, and sleepover etiquette. Meanwhile, Jonny commits to a cat, and the Americans encounter a mysterious substance called Cadbury Chocolate Buttons.
If you enjoy the show, please consider helping defray the costs of making the show by joining us on Patreon at patreon.com/PequodPod
Please also consider telling a friend about the show. Word of mouth is the best way to spread the word about PequodPod, and it helps us tremendously.
Be it said that though I had felt such a strong repugnance to his smoking in the bed the night before, yet see how elastic our stiff prejudices grow when love once comes to bend them. For now, I like nothing better than to have Quequeg smoking by me, even in bed, because he seemed to be full of such serene household joy then. I no more felt unduly concerned for the landlord's policy of insurance. I was only alive to the condensed confidential comfortableness of sharing a pipe and a blanket with a real friend.
SPEAKER_05Welcome to Pequad Pod, the podcast on the Wonder World of Herman Melville. Uh this is the first one of these I've had to say this for in a bit. Oh yes, because we've been speaking with our friends. Yeah, that's why I've been out of the I've been I I I think for the last two episodes I still said it anyway. And then I wasn't, we both times I think Johnny, you corrected me. Hey, we don't have to do that this time.
SPEAKER_04Uh patrons uh they're allowing you to sleep on the job, Tristan. It's true, it's true.
SPEAKER_05Um so today we've got chapter 11, Nightgown, um, which is a very cozy little chapter, uh, which I enjoyed immensely. Meg, do you want to give us one of your classic uh synopses of uh this guy?
SPEAKER_01Yes, this is um this is a favorite. This is a big favorite of one of this early stretch. So Ishmael and Queekweg have a proper sixth grade sleepover this chapter. They're two 11-year-old girls staying up late to watch Buffy on their sister's TV. It's awesome. Um, they sit up in bed talking until around midnight pointedly, um, or Ishmael makes the takes the time to sort of describe their posture, which I always like, which is like they're sitting with their backs to the wall or to sort of a the headboard with their your knees drawn up and um so they can keep their noses on their knees for warmth. Um at some point, sort of the conversation like lulls, Ishmael opens his eyes and he realizes that Queequick has been smoking in bed, which has been forbidden um, I believe, by their all-state renters insurance. But Ishmael sort of pauses before, you know, the automatic rebuke, which he would have done chapters before, but he realizes um that he doesn't care anymore because now, you know, their their relationship has changed. So this value he held has also changed and they smoke together. And at the very last few sentences, um, Kuiqueg begins to tell him about his life, which Ishmael says the next chapter is me doing my best to give you uh my memory of what he of what he told us. So this is another simple chapter, it's like two pages long, but this there's a lot in there. This is very good, sort of like winter vibes, um, sort of the New England winter for sure. It has some of my favorite early bits, um, especially when Ishmael is sort of talking about human experience. I love the part where he's talking about it's better to be slightly cold so as to truly experience coziness, which is different than ambient warmth, which I agree. And I like when he talks about that you have to close your eyes to sit with your or to sort of come into contact with your identity. So there's a lot going on in here, but again, never forget sleepover.
SPEAKER_04Oh, yeah, absolutely. Uh what are your thoughts, Johnny? I mean, I say a variation on this every single episode, but I love this chapter.
SPEAKER_00Is this a good book?
SPEAKER_04I think this book might be pretty good, you know, but for for so many of the reasons that Meg's already mentioned. I mean, just the cozy sleepover vibe that is in the works from the word go is absolutely wonderful. Yeah, I was taken back. I'm kind of eight years old, eight or nine. Uh, got a couple of friends around. We've probably been we've been playing The Sims Unleashed, probably. We've all been out of our minds on lemonade and chocolate buttons. Um, but we're in that lull. It's around this time where we are doing exactly that, chatting and napping. Um, and so and so I love just the really, really strong emphasis on coziness, but the wonderful profundities that that seeming simplicity belies, including but not limited to that sense of yet it's within the real carefully constructed comfort of this kind of environment that we actually are able to interrogate certain aspects of ourselves. This is a text that deals really heavily with questions of identity, and it does right from the right from the very, very beginning, even beyond, you know, even earlier than Looming's. And so we get a really fascinating series of views on it in this chapter uh from a really, really unique, comfortable, cozy context. We're not gonna stay in this state of comfort for very long, and so yeah, okay, but why? Why give us such a touchstone of comfort um in a text that is gonna have all kinds of discomfort laid bare to us, uh, really from a point very, very soon onwards.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think exactly as we go so slowly forward, we'll start to find ways to be like, oh, the nightgown. Life was so simple then.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Yes, the just the beautiful comforts of the safety foot when he's saying that a little part of you needs to stay cold in order to appreciate the warmth. I cannot emphasize how strongly I feel he's right.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. And I really like this as a difference between sort of summer people and winter people.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01And that difference is very psychological, very, very psychic.
SPEAKER_04You're entirely right.
SPEAKER_01I can appreciate the there's romantical and fun things about about all of our seasons. But it's kind of interesting. If you think about the summer person and the winter person, the goal is the same. Warmth. The warmth feels good. The difference is that you have to chase it, you have to create it or find it or protect it in the wintertime. And as Ishmael says, it's a different feeling, which we in the English speaking world call it coziness, to feel like if I leave this blanket, I'm going to be cold. That's different than summertime, which is I'm warm no matter what I do. But sort of that extra step of like, I have to create, I have to create a space where I can experience this pleasure is different because I've had to work for it as opposed to it's sort of being handed to me by the sun. So I think here our author is linking this um protected state that they're in with their knees drawn up and their blanket on with sort of the relationship that they have inside this room where they're sort of doing that, like you were saying, and I felt cozier as you were saying. It's sort of like napping, and then you come back and you talk about something else. And maybe there's like one girl always falls asleep first. That was the same in my sleepers. We have the one friend who like always conked out at like 9:30, and we're like, there she goes. But that like made us feel cosier. But it's something about the space that you're protecting, this sort of like constructed physical state is um wildly different and more pleasurable in that different way than um sleeping outside in the summertime because it's so warm, which is also nice. But it's isn't it lovely that they could find this state of coziness at midnight in a room with no fire in the wintertime in New England?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, absolutely. I mean, it's you you mentioned there's always that one friend who kind of who falls asleep first. Yeah, absolutely. That was completely my experience as well. Sometimes it was me, I think, I have to say. But but there's something to be said, I think, mate, isn't there, about being able to be vulnerable enough in someone's presence that you can fall asleep in front of them. This is somebody that he was horrified by uh an a number of hours ago, and here he is actually that they've put one another in a s in in a really, really comfortable state now where they can make themselves incredibly vulnerable by sleeping with one another. So that's contributing to that sense of coziness and safety as well, I think.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_05Have either of y'all ever read The Poetics of Space by Gaston Bachelin's. Yeah, Gaston Bachelard.
SPEAKER_04Yes, it's wonderful.
SPEAKER_05I I I'm reading it right now, and like it I feel like there's such a uh like a consonance between the two. Like when he talks about the house and winter, and like basically like how the winter, or like especially like the snow, sort of negates the exterior world. And I feel like uh in this chapter, we really get the sense that because of the cold and because of like the coziness and intimacy of this space, like it it's we really get to focus on the relationship between these particular two. It's almost like the rest of the world is like gone for a minute. And I think like one of the things that this chapter really focuses on is like to me, like almost kind of like the the Taoist principle that like uh nothing is without its opposite, right? Like basically opposites are self-arising or like they um arise in concert with one another, um, which is a concept I find very interesting. It's I I don't know if Melville specifically um had any contact with like uh Taoist texts, but I think he sort of has the same ideas, like possibly independently. It's possible that he uh would have encountered Taoism at some point. I don't know. Um something worth looking into, I guess, at some point. But like regardless, he sort of at least instinctually kind of has this idea about how opposites like reinforce each other and emphasize one another. And then I think like the coziness you're talking about with this chapter is like does this also structurally with the rest of the book, right? Here is the spark within the Arctic crystal that we get, right? Here's this cozy thing. The rest of the book's not going to be cozy, but because we have this cozy experience, we are able to develop that uh sort of antithesis of the the non-cozy rest of the book.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, absolutely. And I think there's a really, really interesting and important idea there because what this really depends on is a sense that the outside world actually isn't gone. And I think I if memory, it's been a long time since I've read it, but I get I I feel as if this is maybe something that Bachelard says as well. Like you, it's it's all it's all relative, like in order to and in order to experience that coziness, it gets amplified by the sense of what you're shielding yourself from. It's that sense of being indoors when you can hear hammering rain on the roof, and there's a sense of, oh, thank goodness I'm safe, thank goodness I'm not out there. Yeah. And so maybe that's part of the importance of this chapter, and we've we've already sort of started to intimate it. Like we have this touchstone of comfort so that when we get to those rougher, more tempestuous chapters, it they become rougher and more tempestuous by virtue of what we know they're not.
SPEAKER_05Right. Kind of like uh if we were to uh go off into a different literary universe, uh, like the importance of like the shire being like maximally cozy.
SPEAKER_04Oh, yes, I think that's a really, really good yeah, point of comparison. Yes, that's exactly what it is.
SPEAKER_05I am curious y'all's interpretation of the choice of title in this chapter, because we have a lot of other chapters that are named after a specific thing that gets mentioned in the chapter. I don't think we get a nightgown mentioned in the chapter. Am I missing something here?
SPEAKER_04I don't think so. I'm slightly perplexed by it as well. Yeah. Because the counterpane features very prominently in the counterpane. The carpet bag features slightly less prominently in the carpet bag, um, partly by virtue of its being virtually empty. It is, however, featured. Yeah, nightgown. Interesting.
SPEAKER_01Do we think it's like a metaphor for this sort of feeling? They could, we could say, I think we could place it there that they're probably both wearing one.
SPEAKER_05But we get what they're wearing. Because they're using their monkey jackets. What do we get at the end here?
SPEAKER_01I think they're draped in their jackets because again, they have not lit a fire for reasons.
SPEAKER_05Is Quequeg Ishmael's nightgown?
SPEAKER_04Ah, in the same way that there was no telling where his tattooed arm ends and the and the patterning on the counterpane begins.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, and uh Quequeg throws his legs like he's playing this sort of uh game of contrast again with Ishmael, where he uh what what I'm gonna just pull out what the exact language is. Um he affectionately his brown tattooed legs over mine and then drawing them back again. So entirely sociable and free and easy were we? Yeah, I think it's an open question. Um I did look up to see if like there was some other like use of nightgown, like the word present at the time. But yeah, there's no like uh, as far as I can tell, nightgown's been nightgown for like the last 500 years pretty consistently.
SPEAKER_04So it it's a it's a word that never fails to remind me of Bed Knobs and Broomsticks, that wonderful Disney film where finally at the end they work out the the magic spell for substitutionary locomotion to make inanimate things come to life. And there's that wonderful moment in the in the in the song that they sing because they've worked it out, where uh David Tomlinson as Emilius Brown is is dancing with a a sort of anthropomorphic uh animatronic nightgown. And uh Angela Lansbury as Eglantine Price turns to him with a look of absolute horror and she says, That's my nightgown. And she's horrified that that uh that this that this charming man is dancing with her nightgown. Uh so there we go. Maybe and maybe that conjures up an image of of Ishmael and and and Quequick sort of dancing with one another. I don't know. Didn't we didn't we we talked about Angela Lansbury in a previous chapter, didn't we? Quite recently. She's I think she's getting Is that the uh anti-milk tea drinker? That was what it was. Yes, she's getting a lot of airtime. Friend of the podcast, the late Dame Angela Lansbury.
SPEAKER_03Nothing captain.
SPEAKER_05So we know Ishmael does not have a nightcow. We already know like what he stuffed in his car carpet bag.
SPEAKER_01So it could be. That could be one of the two or three other things he threw in there.
SPEAKER_05Could be, could be.
SPEAKER_01I think he gives us plausible deniability that anything is in there.
SPEAKER_05That's a good point. Yes.
SPEAKER_01That would be my argument. He has any and everything because at once we know, yeah, he gives himself just enough legal cover to say, well, I could have packed it.
SPEAKER_04Well, very much like the Mary Poppins carpet bag, which does have everything in it.
SPEAKER_01It's yes, maybe it is.
SPEAKER_04Angela Lansbury's in the second Mary Poppins film. There we go, she's back again. You can't keep her out of this podcast.
SPEAKER_01We I would never try.
SPEAKER_04Not no, certainly not while I'm around.
SPEAKER_05And kind of going back to our uh extended conversation on the enjoyment of the sleepover, um, we get the line, though daybreak was yet some way down the future. And I think like one of the things in my mind, I'm curious if it was similar for y'all as uh young Meg and young Johnny uh for sleepovers. One of the things about the sleepover that feels so magical as opposed to like uh a friend coming over to play for like a fixed time is that like the sense of time feels like almost limitless in that like you have to cross the liminal boundary of the next day before they like presumably have to go home. Whereas, you know, if they're playing with you like after school or something uh during the afternoon, they have to go home at some point that day. And there's kind of a fixed dread at that fact, and it like kind of undercuts to a certain extent the uh enjoyability of being able to play with them. But if they are there for a sleepover, like that anxiety is like displaced, or like it's there's something like extra uh enjoyable about I get to uh you know stay up basically as late as I want with this person. Um and that like them leaving is put off into like kind of conceptually like a separate thing that's like not in my present or like in my uh direct experience. I don't know if if that was something that y'all experienced.
SPEAKER_04You've uh you've just put something that I experienced so strongly as a child into words in a way that I would never have been able to do. Yes, that was exactly what it felt like. It was it's a perfect metaphor for life in that sense. You feel you feel in a wonderful kind of microcosmic way you feel completely immortal in those in in those moments. Yeah, because that because that end point is never gonna come. It's tomorrow, but it feels just infinitely distant from you in a way that the after school play date doesn't. You're you're so right.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely, and I think um being really young is important with that story because I think if I had a friend come over and we stayed up later and later and later, I'd be like, So my responsibilities are in six hours, five hours, four hours, three and a half hours. And I would feel that in a way that when I was like a Friday night when you're 12 doesn't exist. So yeah, I think I think there's a lot to sort of the idea of like, you know, you're supposed to be asleep, but you're awake, which is interesting already. Um, and then also this idea of like night sort of yeah, puts you in like a separate space where the ending is unimportant. And eventually, probably you do fall asleep, but because that wasn't your goal, it doesn't feel like time wasted the same way it would be if like your mom came in and it was like 10 o'clock, lights out. It's sort of that like adventurous, sort of like Peter Pan feeling of like the night need never end in a way that you kind of grow out of eventually when you have to get your ass up in the morning no matter what.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. I have one memory of um one friend really, really wanted to go to sleep, and the rest of us had had too much lemonade and and chocolate buttons, and uh and so we we were not we were not having it. Um, and I seem to remember walking downstairs in the morning and finding him asleep on the ping pong table because he was so dedicated to wanting to go to sleep that he'd gotten curled up on the only other surface that he could find.
SPEAKER_01Amazing.
SPEAKER_04Very good.
SPEAKER_01I really respect that.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, actually, thinking back on it, fair play to him, resourceful.
SPEAKER_01If you're usually in like a basement, sometimes you're, you know, you're gonna sleep on a strange space. Yeah, why not a ping pong table? It's much better than some of the situations I've found myself in.
SPEAKER_04There's a lovely liminality to a ping pong table, isn't there? Actually, as a place to sleep. Why not? Why not? I feel like I would break it. I don't know, maybe y'all wouldn't, but I think I've got too much of it. But what what you have to remember is my friend was sort of eight years old at the time. There was there was probably about a third of him relative to how much there is of him now.
SPEAKER_01So I think we should talk about this moment in the penultimate paragraph, which is that last really big one that starts. We have been sitting in this crouch manager for a while. Um, and it seems like so Ishmael does one of those interesting things where instead of just like doing something, he tells us that he's about to do something. We get a sort of interesting like theater of narration instead of just narration. Uh, I thought I would open my eyes. Um, I have a way of always keeping my eyes shut in order to more the more to concentrate the snugness of being in bed, because no man can ever feel his own identity aright except his eyes be closed, as if darkness were indeed the proper element of our essences, though light be more congenial to our clay part. Uh yeah, we should feel like we have to linger here for a moment. So, again, instead of just being like, you know, I was kind of dozing and I opened my eyes and saw that he was smoking. This is all I think leading up to realizing that he's smoking. Um, instead, we get this like insane line about uh, I don't know, our our essences. It's like Ishmael cannot help himself, which of course we know is his feature. Um what's going on here?
SPEAKER_05I think this uh has rhymes with uh uh in a previous chapter, like the the the the leaves of uh his better being. Um and so like specifically, okay, we've got the clay part. So like that, you know, if if you missed it, I think it's uh probably obvious. But like, you know, the idea is that, like, at least from like an old testament point of view, that um human beings were initially like shaped out of clay, and God breathes his breath into Adam to create Adam. Um and so the clay part, like, is you know, our bodily uh existence. And so like there's sort of like a platonic uh dualism here between mind and body that uh Ishmael is setting up where like basically it requires like the negation of the external world through his uh experience of it, through his uh like vision, basically, in order for him to like have a sense of who he really is. And so like uh it's like this uh chapter is full of these interesting like contrasts. We get them like again and again and again. We get the the the the like coziness is contingent on being cold to a certain extent, and then like we have this same sort of idea continued here with uh the the like feeling of being who you are requiring like sort of shutting something out so you have that contrast, um, which I think is interesting.
SPEAKER_04You've both just said some really, really fascinating stuff that I and uh that I that I really want to pick up on. First of all, Tristan, the idea of chapters and moments between chapters in a prose text rhyming is just wonderful. Uh, and I've never I I've rarely seen a phrase sail so confidently uh into my own sort of analytical. Vocabulary. That's a gorgeous way of thinking about it. Yeah. Small moments or phrases or narrative instances finding rhyme with moments that come before and after. So that's absolutely fantastic. And we've and the the rhymes that you've spotted there, I think, are absolutely on point. It also speaks really nicely to Meg what you were saying about how strange that moment is temporally, when we get that, to use your phrase, the that moment of the theatre of narrative where he tells us what's about to happen. It is wonderfully proleptic in that sense, right? It looks ahead to something that is about to happen, narratively speaking. It's also, though, really fascinatingly analeptic, being the opposite of Production looking backwards. Because I don't know about you two. I find it singularly weird that he chooses at this moment to tell us that he's had his eyes closed for this entire time. This is where the sleepover vibe slightly um diverges from my own experience in those moments where you're kind of curled up and you're chatting with your friends. Are you two sat there with your eyes closed? I'm not, and I find that really weird. I'm gonna call it out. He sat there with his knees up, because Meggie was saying earlier, this is a wonderfully detailed chapter in terms of postural description. They're kind of sat with their knees up to their chests and kind of with their knees.
SPEAKER_05For our audience, uh Johnny is modelling for us exactly.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean, podcasting, yeah, it's it's it's um it's reliant quite heavily on the listener's capacity to imagine, but I have to do it so that I can picture what they're doing.
SPEAKER_03But so he sat like this, and then he's just got his eyes closed.
SPEAKER_01We might say, just to say that I think it is like pitch black in the room, if that makes it a little better, like they don't have any lights on, right? And the fire isn't going. You could say something a little to their kind of like, you know, you're just like sitting and you kind of just decide I won't fall asleep. It is, I'm not taking, I think absolutely it's kind of like weird to be like, by the way, my eyes were closed this whole time. In a way, it would not have been weird if he had said that up front. You know what I mean? Like we had been sitting and I I let my eyes close, but we talked and I was like, I'm not gonna fall asleep. But instead of just like, it seems like he's yes, he's like, by the way, my eyes were closed, because I was having this deep philosophical moment with myself. And we're like, Here's a question for you.
SPEAKER_05Do you all have your eyes open when you're kissing somebody? Oh. Um no.
SPEAKER_04It depends on on all sorts of circumstances. If you're really kissing somebody, no. If I'm really if I'm really kissing somebody, but I don't really know what that means either. My my sense is probably no. Um, do I do do I allow my eyes to stay open when I give my great aunt a kiss on the cheek? Yes.
SPEAKER_05No, no, in a in a like a a real kiss, like not like uh uh, you know, oh I mean I'm not staring someone down while I'm giving them a little smooch. No. Yeah, I mean there there's a certain intimacy in the eyes being closed, and this is a very intimate chapter.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, keep them keep them shut.
SPEAKER_04You raise a good stuff. I'm I'm I'm I'm giggling at a very uh at what is actually a really good and and perceptive point that you're making, Tristan. So I'm not just thinking about having one's eyes really wide open as you kind of close in to seal the deal with somebody, and just how weird that would be. Maybe as weird as sitting sitting next to your friend with your pointedly with your eyes closed, but also continuing to talk about them about whatever they're talking about when they're chatting and napping.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so they do eventually decide to put a light on. And I guess maybe that's the you know the the big difference that what like 150, I suppose, years probably between when we were having sleepovers and this one, uh, is that they don't have any artificial light going on. You know, at our sleepovers, you got, you know, whatever Sims Unleashed, uh, or like DVD uh menu used in the light going on.
SPEAKER_04Yep, the Shrek 2 uh DVD menu, probably.
SPEAKER_05That's oh my goodness, that probably is the best.
SPEAKER_03Shrek 2? What kind of title is that?
SPEAKER_05Man, the art of a good DVD menu is something lost these days. Oh, it's a lost art. It's a lost art.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_05The Office Base DVD menu is also a really good one when you put it. Yeah, very, very good one. If you like put the DVD in, um, well, well, it it's gonna be on our Melbourne at the movies eventually. But if you put the DVD in, it uh the the message that pops up is that like your DVD has a virus. It's the same virus from the plot of the film, but like it makes you like think for a second, oh no, is there some like major issue with my DVD player now that I put this uh disc in, but then it's the DVD menu. Clever.
SPEAKER_04Oh yeah. Spare a thought for the people who designed those and now have had to. I can't imagine the the the Blu-ray designers fared any better. That very short-lived. Um what are they all doing now?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, it it's interesting. So, like uh, I'm somebody I'm I'm one of those physical media nuts who like does like to buy lots of uh Blu-rays still, but the Blu-ray menu is not the same as like Is it not?
SPEAKER_04I never really delved in.
SPEAKER_05They they don't put the same amount of effort into like the creativity that is evinced in the in you know a crisp early 2000s DVD menu. But uh oh yeah, Anchorman.
SPEAKER_04I seem to remember the Anchorman one being pretty good, obviously having been a uh child instead of and then a teenager in the uh uh early 2000s, uh obviously, um, and particularly and so I guess especially a boy because it was seemed it was very much a sort of um every every boy at school had seen it, no girl had. Um I don't know what the non-I think that's still true watching.
SPEAKER_01I don't want to maybe either in my sleepovers, it was like Fight Club we watched a lot, um Pride of Prejudice, and I seem to recall Mean Girls for a while.
SPEAKER_03What a night followed by Pride and Prejudice. How old are you for this? That sounds like I'm 31, and that sounds like an amazing film night.
SPEAKER_01The the two found the Joe Wright Pride and Prejudice, the Kira Natalie and Matthew McFadge and uh Brenda Blithin. Yeah, we've already got a friend of the pod.
SPEAKER_04Friend of the pod Tom Holland, of course.
SPEAKER_01Friend of the Pod. Um yeah, we had interesting. I if I think about it, yeah, we had we watched like Secretary, we watched um Donnie Darko a lot. I can't explain.
SPEAKER_04Oh Donnie Darko, yes.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's the one.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, terrifying. Gosh, I feel as if straight after we finish, straight after we finish recording here, I'm gonna crack open a bottle of lemonade and some uh and some chocolate buttons, and uh I'll go through into the wee small hours.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, can you please describe what a chocolate button is? Is it just a thing of chocolate?
SPEAKER_04Like, do you know how a cadbury cadbury's chocolate button, of course, you the the craft only acquired the um acquired Cadbury after the end of the of our golden age of the sleepover, of course. Yeah, very small um discs of milk chocolate.
SPEAKER_01Gotcha.
SPEAKER_04Oh no, have I just isolated a huge uh quantity of our uh of our listeners? No, no, no.
SPEAKER_05See, thank goodness. The the the thing is if you have I I don't know if I've actually explained the no two brit policy of mine on the actual air, but it's okay, it's cute because you're explaining the thing to us. It wouldn't work if there were two Brits and you had these inside jokes, and our hugely American audience was not into it, right? So because we're here to be confused by it and have it explained to us, it's endearing and we love it.
SPEAKER_04Oh, but it's generous of you to call my references to chocolate buttons jokes. Um, I dead serious. Exactly.
SPEAKER_05Honestly, when you say, like, oh, uh lemonade and chocolate buttons, it sounds like some kind of fantasy fake thing.
SPEAKER_04It does sound like an iniblighting thing now that I now that I actually slow it down and think about it. There we go. I I was I was one of the famous five. Yes, exactly.
SPEAKER_00That's great.
SPEAKER_04Anyway, enough enough.
SPEAKER_00My eyes are closed in any case, and it's weird. What's going on with that?
SPEAKER_04My eyes have been closed since we started from Christ. But I'm I'm think I'm thinking about my my identity now, and so I'm gonna make the conscious choice to open.
SPEAKER_01Do you think that the darkness is the proper element of our essences?
SPEAKER_04Well, only if it be my own pleasant and self-created darkness, Meg.
SPEAKER_00Otherwise, I think it might just get a business. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Exactly.
SPEAKER_05Exactly. Oh, yeah, we we got a oh yeah.
SPEAKER_00Choice of being.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, we should we should unpack that. I think that is interesting, that distinction that he makes.
SPEAKER_04What do we think of that distinction? It's really, really fascinating in terms of how it contributes to what we've been calling the kind of chiaroscura of the not of the of the of the text that uh Melville's been setting up so far. Uh light juxtaposed very strongly with darkness, white very much strongly, uh very strongly set up as an antithesis with blackness. Um and yeah, exactly the the sense of what darkness can we control and what can we not. We will get the idea further on in the novel of the uh the idea of the Cartesian void that we cannot control and which entails um a certain level of existential dread, which may not be altogether negative, uh, but it is nevertheless something over which we have absolutely no control. Um so yeah, it does seem to um the comfort and the um the kind of comfortable introspection that this darkness allows seems to pivot on the fact it precisely that it is uh contained and that it is also self-constru it is it is constructed by the experiencing self.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, it's the yeah, like Meg was just saying, it's the cold on your the tip of your nose, not the cold of being outside the cozy room.
SPEAKER_04There's an interesting there's an interesting counterpoint with um the that description of Romeo in in I think the first scene of Romeo and Juliet, who's described as um what is it, in his private chamber, pens himself, shuts up his window, locks fair daylight out, and makes himself an artificial knight. That seems like a kind of that that's a melancholy state that's being imposed upon himself by himself. And and it's been created in part by plunging himself into darkness, and also by um convincing himself that he's in love with somebody that he's clearly not in love with. But it's an interesting counterpoint that here we've got a an artificial knight, but that is actually something very positive.
SPEAKER_01What you bring up, Romeo is doing is that uh, you know, sometimes it's like it's good to sort of indulge the sort of like Keatsyan moment of melancholy and like that feel kind of flush it out of your system, like a good cry. So kind of creating that false night. Obviously, things end badly for Romeo, but I bet it felt sort of cathartic. You know, when we talk about sort of states of being. Um but yeah, it's a different darkness. The darkness looks the same to like your eyeballs, but it feels different inside the same way that night feels different when you get to stay up late when you're young versus I'm so angry that I can't fall asleep now that I'm an adult who has to pay rent. It's all contingent, it's all contextual.
SPEAKER_05It gets about uh doubled or uh tripled once you've got uh two little rug rats too. I should think so.
SPEAKER_01I think it's heavy on me just enough. Yeah. I think you know, it's it's enough. I am very tired. And it's just me and my cat.
SPEAKER_04Well, that's the a development that's happened since our last step is that I have acquired a cat. And so this is all this is all she's still there. She is, yeah, for for listeners because because Meg and Tristan know this. Um for to put listeners um to bring listeners up to speed. Yes, we took in a stray cat two weeks ago, um, and we discovered that she was not microchipped. Uh, we also discovered that she was perfect and beautiful in every way. And after two weeks of um doing everything we could, putting up posters and posting in groups, um nobody's come forward to claim her. And so as of yesterday at the time of recording, um she's she's officially ours. So she lives with Angelus.
SPEAKER_01Wow, congratulations. What's the angel's name? Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Her her name, we we she was my partner instinctively called her Luna. Um and that's just the name that stuck, and now it's on it's on some pieces of paper. So that seems to be what we're going with. New old cut of the pod. The vet thinks that she's somewhere between three and four.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So she's like settled in personality, more or less.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, in as much as she's just like a little ragdoll. Yeah, and she just, yeah. That's great.
SPEAKER_00Well, well.
SPEAKER_04That's that's lovely. So there we go. I've got all the I've that I've the weight of responsibility is is is taking shape, but it's uh in a in a nice way. But that's to say I I I I know the feeling of yeah, sort of going, okay. It's maybe not as strong as having two young human beings that you're taking care of. I feel she's um sort of slightly easier than that.
SPEAKER_05It's on the it's on the same continuum. I feel like yes, exactly. It's a good thing, like uh in the run-up to parenthood to have a pet because it imposes on you some requirement to like take care of somebody else. Um, and like, you know, there's uh you can kind of screw up less with like a dog or a cat than you can with a child, but it's on the same continuum. Okay, so we've been talking about the the darkness and like the the contrast there between the eyes closed darkness and the regular darkness. They're uh they're troubled by the darkness, and so they decide to light a lamp, and then also uh Kuiqueg's Tomahawk pipe. Um, what do we think about this transition in our chapter?
SPEAKER_04It bespeaks just how different Ishmael has already become that a couple of chapters ago he was absolutely petrified about the notion of smoking in bed, uh, about his insurance.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, my this is my this is my favorite part of the chapter. Uh, is uh I no more felt unduly spurned for the landlord's policy of insurance.
SPEAKER_01Finally, friendship breaks the powerful hold of capitalism.
SPEAKER_05It does, it transcends so beautiful. I love how like uh uh already our Ishmael is like uh ascribing this concern as being like the the the landlord, the thing that the landlord lord was concerned about, as opposed to like very clearly being like his own fear about this. Absolutely, yeah.
SPEAKER_04He's he's sort of outsourcing his own absolute kind of priggishness and and and and needless anxiety. Yeah, oh well it was Pit Coffin who was concerned about about the insurance. No, it was you. It's interesting that actually in he he he does a lot of of something that we've been talking about in previous chapters, actually of kind of owning his previous misconceptions and his previous mistakes. But it's interesting that there is a moment there where he doesn't do that. Um but that it is about something, it's it's about something kind of rather less interior and rather less integral to the self, a sort of a uh a strongly felt anxiety, yeah, about about insurance and and about and about capitalism.
SPEAKER_01He does say he isn't insured at the end of Spouter Inn. So if they burn their place down, he would be entirely liable for replacing the entire bed and breakfast. So I think that that when he asks landlord, can you tell him to put his pipe out? I'm not insured, is both like you've said in that great word, his priggishness, that's sort of you know, Presbyterian, you know. But it's funnier to sort of think that now he's entirely saying, like, it was the insurance policy. Yeah, default. Well, I mean, why not? I blame insurance policies all the time. Makes me feel great.
SPEAKER_04Don't we all? It's any complaints that we get about this podcast, I blame it on my car insurance.
SPEAKER_01God knows I'm paying enough for it.
SPEAKER_04Indeed. It needs to do something. But but yeah, in uh we we were just mentioning that sense of his owning misconceptions and actually exploring and kind of holding up his interior transformations to the light. And I absolutely love that that little section um that we had as our reading at the beginning of the chapter. Um, though I had felt such a strong repugnance to smoking in the bed the night before, yet see how elastic our stiff prejudices grow when love once comes to bend them. What a gorgeous piece of uh universal uh truth that nothing actually and and and and that came up in it came up in a previous chapter, nothing actually melts prejudices or kind of you know renders them more elastic than love. We've already mentioned Pride and Prejudice, for goodness sake, which which hinges on exactly that.
SPEAKER_00Yes, exactly.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_05So is this uh one of our first instances of a whale oil I'm assuming is a whale oil lamp being used? Oh well, it quite possibly is. Uh, which I might want to highlight because like this intimate encounter between uh Kuiqueg and Ishmael is facilitated by, in some respects, like enabled by their ability to extend light into the darkness and extend extend the day in some respects. Uh they they become troubled by, or like Ishmael does, become troubled by the real darkness, not his like self-created darkness of his eyelids being shut. And it's that like uh um this this trepidation at the real darkness that's exterior to the self that like makes him want to light the lamp um and to use the the the the product of the whale in this way. Uh I think this might be like our most intimate encounter with the the the fruits of this industry that we'll be embarking upon. I don't know if we get it again.
SPEAKER_04That's really, really interesting. Yeah, because I suppose there's an implication that the same lamp is put out at the end of spouter in, for example, but I can't think of another instance where the the act of lighting a lamp is actually mentioned. There's the promised glim that Peter Coffin is going to bring up for Ishmael. I'll get you a glim and a jiffy or the words to that effect. Great word, glim. Great word jiffy. Great, a great sentence for words, that one. Um but uh it's yeah, that's really, really interesting. Because it because of course it will become a real motif, this sense of yeah, the the the light that we exist by, certainly aboard the uh aboard the the pequad exists because of Well and that may yeah, a a good portion of this stage of the relationship between Kuiquegand and Ishmael is illuminated, yeah, by precisely that. That's a really, really interesting point.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, and so like moving us towards the the uh we're gonna get a fantastic chapter next time, but we get like this sort of transition into that. So the the the smoke from the pipe is creating this effect where it like it it seems like they've got a four-post uh bed or whatever, like basically the canopy of the bed is like created by the smoke. I noticed some kind of smoke of some sort uh in your your frame, Johnny, uh earlier on while recording this.
SPEAKER_04Oh, yes. Well, inspired by this chapter and the vibe that this chapter was was was bringing out, I I had a little incense cone burning coming out of this little uh this little incense burner.
SPEAKER_05Oh, okay. I wasn't sure if you had uh I didn't see you smoking, and so I was curious about it because it looked like you had like a cigarette in an ashtray or something. Ah, no.
SPEAKER_00That'd be cool.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, but yeah, so like specifically, like uh smoking is an important theme in this chapter in its like ability to like kind of like this as a social practice. I don't know if we've talked much on the show about like smoking as a social practice. It was certainly important to Melville Melville, uh, as far as I can tell, loved to smoke, though oftentimes uh in isolation. But do we have thoughts on smoking?
SPEAKER_04Well, I uh I'll I'll admit that in my younger and more vulnerable years I did smoke. I don't anymore. Um and I have to say that I do find some of the things described in this chapter and the other kind of communal smoking moments between Kuiqueg and Ishmael quite accessible in as much as it is a social lubricant in many ways. There is a certain intimacy to kind of the sh the sharing of a lighter or the kind of the the lighting of a of a cigarette from another, you know, from another person's cigarette. I know that's not quite what's going on here, but you know, it to kind of translate it into terms that I understand, um, lighting a pipe is something rather different, you know, in terms of you loading the tobacco into the pipe and then the kind of the big sort of the theatre of the little lighted um um sort of splint that you often have to use, and then you kind of get the kind of that kind of that kind of noise. I'm I'm doing another mime for our or for our listeners. Um hopefully they can they can get what I'm doing from the from the foley kind of. That's a great sound.
SPEAKER_01That's exactly it, dude.
SPEAKER_04It's it's inherently quite comfortable.
SPEAKER_01You some kind of actor?
SPEAKER_04No, no, I don't know what gave me that impression. It's not it's not been all the wildly uh the wildly complicated scheduling issues that the last three months have caused. No, not anything like that. I think the the only thing that would the the I I I will never go back to it, but I think the the aesthetic of the pipe I f I find quite endearing. And if I can find a kind of corn cob pipe that but that will blow bubbles, I think I'd go back there. Yeah, for sure. For sure.
SPEAKER_01I would be interested to know. I I um sort of at this point in time, how much that smoking was something that you did with a group of people versus something you did kind of by yourself. My my impression, um rereading at this time, is that it's a little, it's it might supposed to be a little be a little singular that Queekme wants to share the pipe.
SPEAKER_02I don't
SPEAKER_01Think we have yet seen like a bunch of white Anglo-Sailers standing together smoking the way that you and I would sort of think about like the 90s, you know, Sex in the City smoke break, where you stand together and do it. Um where I think I think it's we may be thinking that now that if Ishmael smokes whatever, hand-rolled cigarettes, that's something he does and that's like his business. And it's less something like, do you want to go outside and smoke with me or stay inside and smoke with me? And that we're supposed to recognize the fact that they can smoke together as the sort of pre-wildian sort of like homosocial space where that they're in fact sharing the same smoker is incredibly intimate. Where later we would sort of take that theater as like, um, can I borrow a cigarette? Or you light his cigarette that that sort of becomes um that that has undertones that wouldn't have happened here because it would just simply never happen. But here we get this scene where again uh Melville is giving us sort of a certain kind of cover, or he's asking us to interpret the effect that this um sort of Pacific Islander character, this sort of this other, this sort of cannibal, is so beyond the customs of time and space that he would share his pipe with this person, although it is, as we now know, his wife.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Yeah, uh, I think it's interesting. So, like thinking about like the cultivation of tobacco, like historically. So tobacco is from like the the Western hemisphere. And like specifically, like you know, um, like it's an interesting thing that they are sharing. It's not just a pipe, it's a tomahawk pipe. It's like this intentionally like cannibalistic sort of like uh looking thing. And so there's that aspect of it. So it's like very specifically like it's it's also a weapon. Um two, I I kind of get like uh, you know, there's the like stereotype, like Native American stereotype of like passing the peace pipe, um, which I I don't think is I you know, I I might be uh venturing off into some amount of ignorance. I don't think is like entirely like a uh like not a thing in reality or like not from like some kind of a custom. But like there's at least in the uh uh imaginary of the the the white American, this idea of like uh the indigenous origins of smoking tobacco being like something of a communal thing with the pipe and like associated with like the indigenous person as opposed to like uh what you get later. Like I don't think at this time we have uh machine-produced cigarettes yet. I'm pretty sure we're still, you know, if you're smoking a cigarette, which I don't think is super common at this point in time yet, um, it's certainly gonna be like a hand-rolled cigarette.
SPEAKER_04Um Yeah, we we have the the smokers in this in this text are pipe smokers. Uh I can't I can't think of an instance where I mean a si a cigarette with papers and stuff, uh what one of the worst things that you could possibly take on a on a whaling voyage, I suppose, because the your your Rizzlers are just gonna get destroyed. That's true. No, no, I know. Well, there we go. Um hot tip for anybody for anybody trying to give up cigarette smoking, go on a whaling voyage. Uh you won't be able to smoke cigarettes.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, yeah. That's funny. We uh we will have uh a famous pipe smoker soon.
SPEAKER_04Uh well indeed, yeah. Well, the most inveterate smoker on the peak waters, of course, is of course Stubb. But the other very prominent smoker and then and thereafter ex-smoker is of course Ahab. Yeah. Who should have kept smoking and make it a little bit more?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, is he just grouchy because he's doesn't have to Oh, do you think it's nicotine withdrawal? If he had just worn his patches, none of this would have happened. Yeah, that would have focus on something external. He decided it was a whale, and it's just it's terrible.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, Ahab as like what like the the the picture of uh the the pro so smoking lobby, you know. If you give it up, you're gonna turn into a grouchy Ahab.
SPEAKER_04That's the one, yeah. Lambert and Butler using using him as a as a poster child. Yeah. Other brands of cigarettes are available, but don't smoke kids, it's very bad for you.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. I did have uh um so when you were a smoker, were you a smoker in Italy, Johnny? I feel like it's very hard to be like a non-smoker in Italy.
SPEAKER_04Uh yeah, I think that's probably where it became a thing. I think that that's when I think I probably went from being the the person at the party who would have a cigarette if it was offered to me, to I was the one, I I I had a packet of cigarettes on me. I think that's probably where it changed. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05I I had a a professor uh when I was in Bologna, uh who was like he was one of the professors that led like uh the program for uh like uh Erasmus students uh in Bologna. And his and his advice to us was if you want to go make friends, start smoking. Um and I did, and I made a lot of friends. I've I've quit since, but uh good, good for you. Yeah. Anyway, uh this has been fun, and next time we have an ex especially interesting and fun chapter where we'll get to learn all about the background behind Quequeg.
SPEAKER_00Yay!
SPEAKER_04It's another one of those exciting instances where Melville closes a chapter just before and announces that the next chapter is gonna treat of something. And we had that a a a couple of chapters ago with uh the uh introducing uh Father Maple's sermon. Uh and I love it when writers do that, I love it when they give a certain structural momentousness to something that is on the way, and it's almost it's almost like sort of drawing the curtain uh at the end of a chapter, and then there's a there's potentially like a little scene show, and then it opens and you get to see the thing that uh that's uh that was uh next time hyped up. Exactly. Exactly. It's one of those. And so and I'm and I'm always yeah, I I always love those when it happens. We'll love it.
SPEAKER_05Well, we'll see y'all then. It's gonna be fun. Bye-bye.
SPEAKER_04Don't smoke, kids, it's bad for you. Throw your pipe in the ocean. You've been listening to the Pequot Pot with Tristan Babel Marquise, Meg Fansher, and Johnny Wiles. Our music is by Lost in the Loop with sound engineering by Lauren Aiton. The show's artwork is by Delaney Garrett, and Tristan is on The Synths. We want to say a big thank you to all of our supporters on Patreon. You can join them over at patreon.com forward slash pequag pod for bonus content and for opportunities to help us keep the show running in ship-shaped condition. Ratings and reviews also really help us out, so if you enjoy the show, please do express your thoughts and metaphysical yearnings in the review section wherever you're listening to the show. Tell your friends, tell your foes, tell the white whale on whom you're monomaniacally urged to be revenged. It all helps. Thanks for listening, and until next time, call us the Peacot Pod.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Age of Napoleon Podcast
Everett Rummage