PequodPod
The podcast on the wonder-world of Herman Melville. We're currently reading Moby-Dick and talking about each chapter. We also enjoy and discuss Melville's other works such as Typee, Omoo, Mardi, Redburn, Whitejacket, Pierre, Bartleby, Benito Cereno, The Confidence-Man, Billy Budd, and more!
Support the show: www.patreon.com/PequodPod
PequodPod
Melville at the Movies: In the Heart of the Sea - Preview
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Welcome to PequodPod! The podcast on the wonder-world of Herman Melville.
Here is a free preview of our second Melville at the Movies episode. In this episode, Tristan, Meg, and Jonny discuss Ron Howard's 2015 movie, "In the Heart of the Sea," based on the true narrative of the sinking of the whaleship Essex.
The conversation moves along more dramatically than a CGI whale as we talk truth claims, narrative emphases, and questionable accents, as well as the star-studded cast of actors in this film, which includes Ben Whishaw, Brendan Gleeson, Chris Hemsworth, Cillian Murphy, and a wee-little Tom Holland.
We also debate the subject of who should play Herman Melville in the future PequodPod-produced, 3-hour gay biopic before coming to THE DEFINITIVE CONCLUSION.
You can enjoy the full bonus episode by joining us on Patreon at patreon.com/PequodPod at the Stubb, Starbuck, or Ahab levels.
Please also consider telling a friend about the show. Word of mouth is the best way to spread the word about PequodPod, and it helps us tremendously.
Also, if you live in the United States and haven't already, go vote!
Yeah, so one of the things I find really interesting about this movie is that it's as far as I can tell, the only movie that Herman Melville, like as the the author Herman Melville, is a character.
SPEAKER_03Two thumbs up.
SPEAKER_01I can't think of any others.
SPEAKER_03Just toss him in more. Have we considered putting Herman Melville in this historical drama? We should.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no. He's public domain. Yeah, so I I asked friend of the show, uh, Dr. Hester Blum, if like there was anything else that she could think of where uh Herman Melville is a character in like a film. And she couldn't think of anything else besides this movie as well. So I think it's interesting from that perspective. So this being our second Melville at the movies, uh, cue the theme music. Um I think it's a worthwhile one, like for a number of reasons, but like it's specifically, it's very interesting because we are like specifically a Herman Melville podcast. This is the all this is all we got. So let's uh start with uh this portrayal of Herman Melville. So Ben Ben Wishwell.
SPEAKER_03Ben Wishaw, yes. Also John Keats in an interesting movie. He's been in many things, but I I particularly liked his his that sensitive turn. He has a sort of face that makes you think he must be a writer.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Yeah, known for bright star, uh, known uh as Q in the more recent James Bond films, uh, known as a wonderful Shakespearean actor. I saw him play Brutus at the Bridge Theatre in London a few years ago. Um his Magnum opus, of course, um is the well I'd say Paddington Barry. Paddington.
SPEAKER_00Paddington. Paddington? Sorry.
SPEAKER_01Yes, I was gonna I I was gonna say trilogy of films, but it's more like a Wagnerian Gesamtkunstverk in three parts. Um Paddington, Paddington 2 and Paddington Peru, my top three films. Um I need to find some level of sort of resonance with Moby Dick for all three of those films to make it into Melville of the movies.
SPEAKER_02For me, I would I guess expect I guess because like I don't know, I've read uh so much of what like Melville's written, and I am curious like to what extent like him as writer compared to him as like a real life person, like uh the extent to which they're they would have been similar. But like I always get like a very more kind of exuberant person, like kind of a like a very intense presence, which I don't think is something that we get from this Melville in this film. Like he's a little bit more of a subdued presence and like kind of an introspective presence.
SPEAKER_03Well, we have to think of what is his job as a movie character. He has to get the ball rolling for this guy to tell a story. He's not our storyteller necessarily, but he's gotta initiate the storytelling from the other person. He kind of has to be a little more prickly and sort of having maybe what is more sort of an Ishmaelian Dark Knight of the Soul, rather than maybe you and I would sort of think of as our idea of the real Herman Melville. He's gotta be make get the movie going, Herman Melville.
SPEAKER_02I I don't know if y'all looked into like this opening quote that we get delivered by Melville's character that's like basically supposed to be quoted material from the letter he writes to Nickerson. Uh, I don't believe that it's like uh a real quote. I haven't been able to like I I did some digging to see if like any of this is borrowed from like any real Melville text, and I don't think it is, but um Let's hear it, yeah.
SPEAKER_00How does one come to know the unknowable? What faculties must demand possess? Since it was discovered that whale oil could light our cities in ways never achieved before, it's created global demand. It has pushed man to venture further and further into the deep, blue unknown. We know not its depths, nor the host of creatures that live there. Monsters. Are they real? Or do the stories exist only to make us respect the sea's dark secrets?
SPEAKER_01That sounds like a very Ishmael thing to say. I don't know whether it strikes me as a particularly Melville thing to say or to write. And so I wonder whether that is sort of leaning into this slightly more Ishmaelian introspection and quirk, and maybe feeds into the idea that actually there's a sense that the audience is being nudged to see a Melville that resonates more with Ishmael because that's possibly what anybody who's coming to this film with a knowledge of, even a passing knowledge of Moby Dick is going to be expecting.
SPEAKER_03Which is why they end with the sentence that they end with.
SPEAKER_01Precise.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think that's exactly right. I believe that this is exposition made entirely for this movie, because I don't think anyone in the time would have needed to write, you know, whale oil, that thing that lights our world. Yeah. What is a monster? They're trying to get us excited, much like the beginning of Moby Dick, to see a whale.
SPEAKER_02Certainly.
SPEAKER_03Because that's what's on the poster.
SPEAKER_02I think I would have liked it if they were able to find like some real uh Melville material to quote. Because I to me it's like what maybe like kind of a dumb person would think Melville would write. Or like it sounds sort of like Melville.
SPEAKER_03I think that's exactly what they were yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's although, just to just to roughen the surface of that, because I think that's a really interesting idea, I suppose it kind of invites the question: which Melville is saying that at the beginning of the movie? Is this the Melville who has gone on to write Murby Dick? Yes. Is this the Melville who has only so far written Call Me Ishmael? Is this the Melville speaking before he's met with Thomas Nickerson? Because those are set up as actually quite subtly, but I think definitely as very, very distinctive figures in them in the movie.
SPEAKER_02So we know it's we know it's number three, because in like later in that exposition, uh it becomes clear that this is like specifically a letter to Nickerson. It's the letter that he's sending before he gets to meet him.
SPEAKER_01Aha. So there we go. If it sounds a bit like crap Melville, is that the point? Because we haven't got the point. Yes, you know, and I don't I I hope that that's not intended as a facetious question. You know, how are we are we being invited to think about this Melville, who, smack bang in the middle of the movie, says, I'm not a great writer. That sounded more like Gore Vidal than Ben Wishwell was having Melville. But um, but there we go.
SPEAKER_03Chill, buddy, chills.
SPEAKER_01I I don't claim to do a good wish or something.
SPEAKER_03Please put a bit in that. Do less. Oh goodness. Where exactly Chris Emsworth is from I I need to hear this question.
SPEAKER_01I'm so excited.
SPEAKER_03Please.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so assuming that the podcast continues to rake in dough and we we we get the budget for it, if we were to create our own ideal Herman Melville film, because again, this is the only film that I am aware of that has any depiction of Herman Melville as a character in it, how would we do it?
SPEAKER_01Oh, I mean, uh gay biopic of Melville and Hawthorne.
SPEAKER_03It's called the Cave.
SPEAKER_01It's called the Cave. And who do we want? Um Oh. We hope you've enjoyed this preview of Melville at the movies. You can listen to the full episode and access more bonus content by going to patreon.com forward slash pequod pod and subscribing at the Stub, Starbucks, or Ahab level.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Age of Napoleon Podcast
Everett Rummage