PequodPod
The podcast on the wonder-world of Herman Melville. We're currently reading Moby-Dick and talking about each chapter. We also enjoy and discuss Melville's other works such as Typee, Omoo, Mardi, Redburn, Whitejacket, Pierre, Bartleby, Benito Cereno, The Confidence-Man, Billy Budd, and more!
Support the show: www.patreon.com/PequodPod
PequodPod
Episode 11: A Bosom Friend
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Welcome to PequodPod! The podcast on the wonder-world of Herman Melville.
In this episode, we investigate the gayest chapter thus far in Moby-Dick: "A Bosom Friend." Tristan thinks it should have been named "The Marriage," and Queequeg and Ishmael do indeed get hitched in this one. Also, happy belated 175th birthday Moby-Dick!
If you enjoy the show, please consider helping defray the costs of making the show by joining us on Patreon at patreon.com/PequodPod
Please also consider telling a friend about the show. Word of mouth is the best way to spread the word about PequodPod, and it helps us tremendously.
If there yet lurked any ice of indifference towards me in the pagan's breast, this pleasant, genial smoke we had soon thawed it out and left us cronies. He seemed to take to me quite as naturally and unbiddenly as I to him. And when our smoke was over, he pressed his forehead against mine, clasped me round the waist, and said that henceforth we were married. Meaning in his country's phrase that we were bosom friends. He would gladly die for me if need should be. In a countryman, the sudden flame of friendship would have seemed far too premature, a thing to be much distrusted. But in the simple savage, those old rules would not apply.
SPEAKER_03Tristan? I am indeed, yeah. Good.
SPEAKER_00How sweet do you take it?
SPEAKER_04Oh, not at all. I don't put any sweetener in it.
SPEAKER_00I drank tea juice, so like people take, I'm like, you want to sip? Thirsty, and they're like, yeah, and they like spit take it out like we're in like a screwball comedy with like Carrie Grant.
SPEAKER_03Tea juice.
SPEAKER_00It's very, very sweet. It's very sweet. My mother, her family from like the Kentucky area drank it sweet, and I have progressively gotten a sweeter tooth. So it's almost unbearable.
SPEAKER_03Are you are you having milk as well? Or is it you're just some lemon and some honey? Ah, so you shun you shun the milk?
SPEAKER_00I don't do milk. I know we never we never did that growing up.
SPEAKER_04So do you take are you taking your tea hot or is it iced tea?
SPEAKER_00Hot.
SPEAKER_03And it has lemon and honey and sugar. You're like you're like Angela Lansbury's character in Nanny McPhee when she's offered a cup of tea and and I think it's Colin Firth who says milk, and she says, certainly not. Nasty common stuff. And then she and then he really hesitantly asks sugar, and she says, Six, if you please. You're you're you're that character. I can't remember what she's doing. She's like Aunt Agatha or Aunt Something.
SPEAKER_00Something around. Yeah, it's like a weird um like class indicator or something. Like I yeah, it's uh it's a rich text, the the teacup for sure.
SPEAKER_01The teacup as text. Hi, I am Don from Concord, New Hampshire. Welcome to Pequod Pod, the podcast on the Wonderworld of Herman Millville. I'd like to give a shout out to my awesome daughter Rose and say, oh, many are the Finbacks and many are the Derricks, my friend, to her, because that's our favorite part of the book.
SPEAKER_04Oh, you might be hearing some electrician noises. Do you hear a bandsaw in the background? Yes, indeed. Yes, we do.
SPEAKER_00It adds texture.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so uh the thing that my dryer plugs into needs to be replaced. And so they're working on replacing that. The thing that your dryer plugs into? The wall? The wall? Well, not the wall. The the thing, like not the actual plug. The outlet. The outlet. The outlet.
SPEAKER_03It's a good job you've got a professional in the house, Tristan, because you it sounds as if you would be lost trying to solve this problem for yourself.
SPEAKER_00Maybe the same dudes who did Johnny's bathroom could fix your wall.
SPEAKER_03Well, they are now finished.
SPEAKER_00So um that's the next job. And God bless them. I wish I had a skill.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I don't. I'm really jealous of all these things.
SPEAKER_03Your skill is summarizing and then discussing.
SPEAKER_00Oh god, I haven't written my thing to do summarizing. It's gonna be completely off the top of my head. I missed my one thing.
SPEAKER_03Good thing you have this skill, Meg. Why don't you what and what a beautiful my my skill is is doing really, really sort of um ham-fisted segues. Meg, why don't you summarize this chapter for us? Well, you bastard.
SPEAKER_00So this is this is a great chapter. This is another one of our, you want to say maybe a quiet heavy hitter. We want to say, oh, the sermon, this is a big deal, and the thing when they're in bed that's obviously big. Like when people talk about the book, there are certain moments that, you know, bubble up sort of organically as like the turning point and the things like this. This is a really sweet bow tied on one of the early plot lines. Um, this is essentially largely summarized prose where Ishmael comes back from chapel, finds Kuiqueg, who pieced early in their room doing something that might be called reading. He's kind of looking at a book, but Ishmael's interpretation of it is that he's kind of just like charmed to be looking at this object, but is not necessarily reading it the way that we would be reading a novel. You might even think the implication is that he has not seen a book before. We'll talk about that. But um, as Ishmael watches Kuiqueg do this, Ishmael sort of reflects to himself how really lovely the bearing and um the body, and kind of just the vibes of Kuiqueg are really good. Um, he's seeing a lot of green flags, as we would say. And um as sort of this uh bubble of affection reaches his apogee, he um asks to what's the cute phrase that he uses? Soon I propose a social smoke. There we go. I read this chapter before our meeting. Um they smoke together out of his um tomahawk pipe, and then um they embrace, they press their foreheads together, and then straight up uh Kuiqueg says, henceforth, we are we're married. Um direct dialogue, but still. Um, and then Ishmael says, the way you and I would say this, we're saying bosom friends, but um, they eat supper, they smoke again, they hang out. Kuiqueg makes the motions like, Do you want to do my thing? I went to your church, do you want to do mine? And Ishmael has this interesting moment where he's like, Okay, this is pagan worship, which average Joe on the street would say is idolatry and is bad. I'm a good Presbyterian. But then he's like, Well, if by being a good friend or doing this sincerely is actually really what God wants from like his ideal Christian. So it's actually totally kosher, as it were, to go through this sort of ceremonial blessing, even though this isn't my church or even my God. It seems that like this brings them to glip together um even closer. And um, they get in bed together and kind of gossip, and then they go to sleep in their honeymoon. And it is from beginning to end, honestly, a very sweet, um, sincere, pretty free of irony, um, lovely chapter just about um boys being boys.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think Meg has hit on so many things that we're gonna want to talk about. It's where the queer aesthetics that we've gestured towards, at the very least, uh, in previous chapters uh comes to something of a head. I think anybody uh who is trying to deny in this chapter that what we have is a queer narrative between Ishmael and Kuiqueg, it's gonna be an uphill struggle for them. Um I'm really, really fascinated by the way that it is that it's portrayed. I'm really, really interested in the uh placement of this chapter following on from the sermon for several different reasons. Yes, uh um, which I'm sure we'll get on to. Um I'm also, and Meg has already intimated this, the fact that actually so much of this uh relatively kind of straightforward uh plot has so much going on beneath the surface, dialogue is suppressed in a way that's really fascinating, following on from the sermon, which contains by far the most quoted speech that we have in the text so far. So structurally, thematically, as well as narratively, I think it's an absolutely fascinating chapter. I'm really excited to see what kind of threads we're gonna be gonna be picking up.
SPEAKER_04One of the uh books of the Bible that we get uh a reference to in the sermon is 1 Corinthians, the book of the New Testament that I think dwells the most on like idolatry and like turning from idolatry. Um, and getting like that reference. So specifically in the sermon, we get where Father Maple says, uh while preaching to others is himself a castaway. Um and so specifically, so we get this like uh we we we already have First Corinthians on the mind as the immediate context of Ishmael like basically like violating like pretty severely like uh some of the admonitions we get from the pilot Paul as it relates to idolatry and turning from idolatry. And so I I think it's like an interesting, intentional thing to set those two up next to each other. Um like to compare and contrast, if you will, between like this uh uh this Christian gathering and then this uh pagan form of worship.
SPEAKER_03I'm really interested actually in the specific act that Quequeg's engaged with at the beginning of the chapter. So what do we get? We uh Ishmael tells us, yeah. Um he was sitting on a bench before the fire with his feet on the stove hearth, and in one hand was holding close up to his face that little negro idol of his, peering hard into its face, and with a jack knife gently whittling away at its nose, meanwhile humming to himself in his heathenish way. I'm really interested in the fact that this uh little idol, which we find out, I think, in a couple of chapters time is called Yojo, seems to be some kind of work in progress. Why is he whittling him? Is Yojo in some way a finite resource and the this act of worship that he's engaged with involves actually cutting away at him and that at some point eventually Yojo will be will be used up? Or is there a sense that Yojo is actually in a process of continual definement? Is this whittling actually making Yjo, I don't know, more detailed or more apt to be used for the act of worship? It's really, really nonspecific, and there are all sorts of non-specific things going on in this chapter with regard to the the function of things. I'm thinking in particular of the book that Kuiqueg is quote unquote reading. He's he's examining it sort of a bit later in the chapter.
SPEAKER_04I think it's interesting thinking about like what's happening to uh Yojo. So specifically, what do we get? We get him is he carving him a new nose?
SPEAKER_03Carving away at his nose, giving him giving him a nose job.
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes. I kind of like the idea of like the the idol as like a living document, and his appearance changes as Kuiqueg's needs or relation to kind of his faith in that moment changes.
SPEAKER_04Um I like that.
SPEAKER_00Presumably, if Yojo gets small enough, he can make a new one. And it's not that it's this wood that is the sacred thing in the sense that it might be like a reliquary or in like the church, in like a Christian church, but that um as outward symbol he changes to fit my needs rather than the other way around, which is an interesting way to contrast, sort of like most Abrahamic, I think the three Abrahamic religions are like, well, the book is kind of fixed and our interpretation of it changes, or I have to modify my appearance or my behavior or my thoughts to fit with the canon that's a thousand years old or whatever. We might be getting another option for relation to the external symbol of the god.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I like that a lot, and especially in relation to thinking about Quequeg as a tattooed being, right?
SPEAKER_03So yes, his body is a text as well.
SPEAKER_04Right. And that's like a continual process, right? You get it, you know, if if you're someone who uh gets tattoos, I I don't have any tattoos. I know Meg's got tattoos. Johnny, do you have tattoos? No, I'm pure as the driven snow.
SPEAKER_00Wow, okay, boys.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, um anyway, uh uh non-sequitur aside, uh, but yes, like thinking about um the like the parallel between like uh Yojo as being this uh being that's continually being remade and like the act of tattooing as like a similar uh function, right? Like, you know, if you get if you keep getting more tattoos or your tattoos continue to develop over time, you're also sort of this being that's continually being remade. And I think you're uh I really like your point about like that from a religious perspective, Meg. And I think like we get this too when we get later in this chapter about how Ishmael really like uh marvels at the Socratic aspect of Kuiqueg, or like the like how like Kuiqueg seems like this great philosopher, or like would seem like a great philosopher from a Western perspective, but he's not like kind of self-conscious of that as like being a pursuit that he has. Like basically um this being like Kuiqueg's existence as this continually like uh self-creating, like uh primal thing that like is seems lost or like something that we don't have like in Western culture anymore. Instead, we have like this these kind of uh stayed or uh fixed texts and these fixed sorts of roles, and there's there's not this same kind of uh ability to like continually self-develop. Um and I think that's like what gets so attracts him to Queequeg.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, certainly. And I don't think it's a coincidence, therefore, that we see an enormous phase of self-development in Ishmael in this chapter, where we get that something that we've been mentioning quite a bit actually in these early kind of landbound chapters, especially in the spouter in is that gradual process of Ishmael's affective opening, his becoming more open and perceptive of and amenable to his fellow human beings. And this is where I think that process reaches a real milestone. And perhaps the things that we've been saying actually really contribute to that the end of that part of this process, uh when we get um the following which I think is absolutely extraordinary. As I sat there in that now lonely room, the fire burning low, in that mild stage when after its first intensity has warmed the air, it then only glows to be looked at, the evening shades and phantoms gathering round the casements and peering in upon a silent, solitary twain, the storm booming without in solemn swells, I began to be sensible of strange feelings strange feelings we definitely need to come back to. I felt a melting in me. No more my splintered heart and maddened hand were turned against the wolfish world. This kind of spininess and kind of antipathy that has characterized the Ishmael of these early chapters finally well in the words of the text itself melts away and something happens here. He is alert and alive to interpersonal relationships now in a way that he really hasn't been up to this point in the text.
SPEAKER_00I think that's interesting too to come back to the something you said at the beginning, which is like why this chapter after the last chapter. Something that I was thinking about is like we kind of discussed this when we discussed the chapter, the sermon, which is that Ishmael, for intents and purposes, is not really in the chapter. He doesn't speak and we don't get his interpretation or anything first person. Chapter 10, notably, is also absent of any like metabolizing of this the thing he just heard. He doesn't appear to mull it over or like did you listen to that thing? Like something we could have seen. So I'm kind of wondering if like the way that we are to understand that he heard something in the previous chapter that it affected him is this um willingness or this sort of like awakening that had started the night before. And he is now ready to kind of articulate it in a way that he wasn't able had he not gone to the sermon, which is this thing about that he and I are starting kind of this two-person community in this bed. We're we're in a new relationship in this space, and we ritualize it, and now we're on the other side of it. So come what may, I have a bosom friend now, where if we had not had the sermon, he wouldn't have been able to make that jump. I don't think that's explicit necessarily. And I wouldn't even really argue that the things he's thinking about in a bosom friend have necessarily the same things to do that he was talking about in the sermon, but surely there it must be some connection from the one to the other, or there would have been another chapter between these two. So I the author is asking us to continue to link the next thing with the thing that came before it, you know, plots. So it's like, why not? We uh we are reading for clues. So it may be there that Ishmael is like, I have I have thawed enough that I see it in this person who is now my friend, and I can use that word.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I like that a lot. And I I do think we have like kind of direct evidence of kind of what you're talking about, like that connects the two in the paragraph starting, um, I was a good Christian, born and bred, blah, blah, blah, blah. Um, and then we get uh, how then could I unite with this wild idolater in worshiping this piece of wood? But what is worship, thought I? Do you suppose now, Ishmael, that the magnanimous god of heaven and earth, pagans and all included, can possibly be jealous of an insignificant bit of black wood? Impossible. But what is worship? To do the will of God, that is worship. And specifically, I think that line there. So, but what is worship? To do the will of God, that is worship, um, like parallels very strongly, like kind of like the specific language of the sermon. And like specifically the uh the emphasis on doing the will of God is like the like the the main theme of the sermon. And it's interesting to me because like I I'm not sure that whether Father Mapple would like agree with how Ishmael is sort of like interpreting the sermon here. Um, and because like especially like uh I mentioned earlier, like one of the like the second most important text for uh the sermon, um so after Jonah being like uh 1 Corinthians, based on at least what's cited, like it is very against this idea of like joining with idolaters. And we actually get this specifically uh in 1 Corinthians chapter 10, verses 14 through 22, which if if you don't mind, I'm just gonna read real quick.
SPEAKER_03Please do.
SPEAKER_04Wherefore, my dearly beloved, flee from idolatry. I speak as to wise men, judge ye what I say. The cup of blessing which we bless, is it not the communion of the blood of Christ? The bread which we break, is it not the communion of the body of Christ? For we being many are one bread and one body, for we are all partakers of that one bread. Behold, Israel, after the flesh, are they not they which eat of the sacrifices, partakers of the altar? What say I then, that the idol is anything, or that which is offered in sacrifice to idols is anything? But I say that the things which the Gentiles sacrifice, they sacrifice to devils and not to God, and I would not that ye should have fellowship with devils. Ye cannot drink the cup of the Lord and the cup of devils. You cannot be partakers of the Lord's table and of the table of devils. Basically, by joining with idolaters, you're because you, uh at least in Paul's view, by becoming Christian are like joining like in union with Christ, if you if you unite yourself with like uh any number of things that like aren't good, but like especially in in this uh particular uh epistle uh to uh idolaters, you are you also uniting like basically those devils or those idolaters with the body of Christ. And so like we get this like very kind of specific admonition against doing what Ishmael's doing in this epistle that like we got uh cited in the sermon, uh, but he's gonna do it anyway, and sort of like uh have his own kind of logic for why that's okay. So I'm gonna quote one more time from 1 Corinthians on a different subject, which I think is interesting. So there's a little bit of a tension here, and I think like it from like a biblical perspective, the the marriage to Quequeg is more justified than the uh idolatry with Quequeg. And specifically, um if we go to chapter uh seven in 1 Corinthians uh 14, for the unbelieving husband is sanctified by the wife, and the unbelieving wife is sanctified by the husband. Else were your children unclean, but now they are holy. And this is in this section, basically, like uh it's about Paul talking about like whether or not people should get married or like separate if they are already married, and like specifically the you know, he's addressing the question, hey, what if you're a Christian, but like, you know, you just converted and your uh spouse is still a pagan, should you like leave them? And he says, no, and that like by them being married to you as a Christian and like you being like kind of joined through that marriage, they're also gonna be saved through you, basically, which is kind of interesting. I feel like that's not something that's like uh really promulgated by the church this uh today, but in in a sense, in the same uh Pauline Epistle, we kind of have like the idea that because specifically like Kuiquag and Ishmael are married now, from like a certain uh Christian perspective, uh Ishmael is saving Kuiquag for uh for Christ.
SPEAKER_03So interesting. Although, were it not for the fact that this is not what would at least in a 19th century capacity be thought of as a conventional marriage, right? And we've uh we've spoken about loads of different things to do with this chapter up to this point, and we we are circling around the fact that this is by far and away the gayest chapter we've had so far. Um, and it would be incredibly remiss to us not to let's let's let's get gay, let's get gay.
SPEAKER_00I'll meet with my gay glasses on over here.
SPEAKER_04We've gotten feedback, we're not a gay enough podcast. So far. And so we need to up the gay. Um, yes.
SPEAKER_00Well, how how to begin? I know we've said this many times, but it does bear repeating. Sometimes, you know, it you're you think to yourself, Am I reading too much into this? Is it that deep? The English teacher argument to that is, is it written down? Then you can read into it. And everything that we receive in the book was written by the author. I think we've said a couple of times, like sometimes you can forget that it was like made by someone and that everything that's on the page was a decision. And so we are looking at this chapter in a lot of extraordinary decisions that didn't have to be there. Like if this looks gay to us. How gay did it look in 54 whenever it was published? So on a lot of different levels is this an interesting text, this chapter. We talked about why is it coming off the previous chapter? Why is it written the way it is? And this kind of like, like he's kind of I my idea is he's kind of narrating it like from the ceiling. We didn't he no one talks, or he likes it's it's written like he's summarizing everything, which is an interesting level of like intimacy. But straight up, we're using the language of matrimony. We've kind of used that language in previous chapters, but only comparatively. So I think in the counterpane or something like that, he says it's like we were married, like or as if almost, yeah. Yeah, it was like I was his wife. You would have thought I was his wife. That's I mean, that's a shocking word, but still we're given enough, we're given some gray area in the sense that it's as if I was his wife. It's like, or you would have thought that I was. There's that degree of removal here, straight up, Kuiqueg is like, we're married. That's the word that he uses, said that henceforth, we were married. Now we do get a semicolon, and Ishmael kind of softens it in the sense that, okay, if we were two white American guys, both went to Presbyterian church, we would just say that we were bosom friends, which is the name of the chapter. But Herman Melville did not have to put that other part in there first, and he did. So he is asking us to think about them as a married couple. It's not reading that in too deep.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. No, I 100% agree with you. And one of the things I think is interesting is the choice and title. I feel like to a certain extent, like there's some self-censorship there. Where like I feel like the real title of this chapter ought to be The Marriage.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, married. I agree. Yeah. Yeah. And that's our note for Melville.
SPEAKER_03How dare he die in 1891.
SPEAKER_00Come back.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Yeah. No, I think like uh I think you're totally right. And I think it is interesting that like you he has to soften it like that. Um because yeah, like he could, yeah, you're right. He could have just said that, or he could have said, now we're blood brothers or something, or something that doesn't have this like uh homo erotic quality to it. But he chooses the thing that is the most charged that way. And then he continues with it. He uh, you know, uh he he talks about at the end of the chapter.
SPEAKER_00They're in their heart's honeymoon.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah, their heart's honeymoon, and thus then in our heart's honeymoon, lay I and Quequeg, a cozy, loving pair. And he talks about how right before that, how man and wife open the very bottom of their souls to each other. Yeah, I I I challenge anybody who doesn't think this book is gay to explain explain this chapter to us.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's I I just I really don't think it can be done. I think it requires such a strong reading against the narrative and interpretive grain to try and suggest that it's just oh, that they're just friends, they're just roommates. Because as you say, Meg, it's there on the page, and Melville has chosen to put it there. We don't have to go looking for it. We are not carrying out a queer reading of this chapter. I mean, I'm I'm all in favor of doing that, but you don't have to be carrying out a queer reading of the chapter to spot that these things are going on.
SPEAKER_00And yes, we can just say it is a queer chapter, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Exactly. The burden of proof is on anybody to show that it isn't.
SPEAKER_00So then the interesting like question becomes why? What is the point of these two having this interesting relationship? Why spend this time? What are we getting from this text that we then take to chapter 11 and then we then we then take to chapter 12? So that when it is 50 chapters away from this, what good does it do us to say, oh, these two are married?
SPEAKER_04I I think that part of it is that Ishmael, like, and we get this earlier, it's worth a mention. Yeah, I'll try a pagan friend, thought I, since Christian kindness is proved, but hollow courtesy. Um, and I think that like basically we have like a few different reversals here. So Ishmael, like the Ishmael that we get, like, is sort of this friendless person who's like feels very alienated from his like Christian, uh like white American world. And he basically goes as far against that in terms of his like first real friend as possible. So, like, one, it's like a queer relationship, two, this is uh someone who's not Christian, and three, it's someone who's not white. And so I think like him latching on to Queekweg and like really having this like a very deep uh attachment to and like this relationship with him is like basically as like far away from like what would be expected of like a presumably white young man in this time and place.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, certainly. I think that's absolutely true, and it paves the way as well for the deeply, well, so at the very least, homosocial environment that we will get on the Pequod. It's uh populated exclusively by men who form incredibly tight bonds with one another. Uh, it is also, I would argue, a queer space, CF, a chapter that we'll talk about in well, quite a few months' time, a squeeze of the hand, where male bodies and male selves engage in an activity which involves them losing a sense of distinctive selves and actually in the text in terms kind of seeping into one another. Um, so I think it's there's something to be said about the queerness of wailing and how that's gonna underpin a a significant portion of the rest of the text as well.
SPEAKER_00Can I say something cute?
SPEAKER_03Well, please, please, please, please. Please.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, don't forget what you're gonna say, but I want to say this before I forget. It's it's so this is a quick one-off, but I think it's maybe cute to reframe why Quequeg was in the chapel in the previous chapter. I think when you hit that chapter going forward the first time, it's like, oh, what a coincidence. We're both here in the same chapel. Here, we might be able to go backwards and say he went there because he knew Ishmael would be there. And now he's inviting Ishmael to do his thing. So Quequeg has a hand at the wheel here to do to make this ritual.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So it was not a coincidence that he would. I mean, he left early because you know, he was like, I got things to do. Church is the same, but um, still it's this idea that you're we're swapping. I know you're not worshiping my idol, but like I did your thing, and now you did my thing. This this whole thing is kind of orchestrated by his hand, I think is really sweet.
SPEAKER_03I love that as a way of attributing Queen Quake some agency in the in the process. And hey, marriage is all about compromise. So and so being in the middle, absolutely, and that's that a version of that is what seems to be happening here.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, and you could even say, like, uh, so to to to go further, um, so he leaves early, so that Ishmael has to go find him, and uh he finds him with his idol.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. Oh, that's kind of fan fiction-y in a good way. It's kind of like you see the hand of like the puppet master later, you're like, ooh, I I I see how I was actually um steered here when I thought it was um by happenstance. That doesn't only happen in fanfiction, but that can often happen.
SPEAKER_03I'm actually incidentally now what while we're uh while we're on the subject, I'm only just noticing now that we get that really strong emphasis on the whittled nose of Yojo at the beginning of the uh of the chapter. And then towards the end, when they are actually performing the little ritual together, we get so I kindled the shavings, helped prop up the innocent little idol, often burnt biscuit with Kuiqueg, salamed before him what uh twice or thrice, kissed his nose, and that done, we undressed and went to bed. The implication there is that Kuiqueg and Ishmael both kissed the nose, and so it's like that thing at school where you know, because you've both touched the same thing, or because you've both like kissed the same bit of a tree or whatever, it means that you've kissed. Like there is that Yojo is actually the most rules stand for the rest of your life.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely.
SPEAKER_03I couldn't agree more. But but Yojo actually becomes the becomes the proxy for them actually sharing a kiss here, right?
SPEAKER_00You're right, good job. That's really gay. That's good. That is cool. Yeah, that's sweet. That's good. I like that.
SPEAKER_03Are they are we actually looking at a little thropple or a little polycule here? And and Yojo is uh is uh is is is a member of it.
SPEAKER_00That's right. That's nice. So like the dowry he kind he attempts to give him. Well, he does get he kind of forces it upon him. We get 30 pieces of silver, which is you know very interesting, but it only gives him half. And he's like, no, take it. It I think does prompt the question of does Kuiqueg do this with every roommate, or is it just Ishmael? You think he's done with this priority?
SPEAKER_03Oh, do you mean not these are his moves when he wants to lure a guy?
SPEAKER_00And the other guys are like, Oh my god, that's his new ship wife. Does he have 15 pieces of silver? And Ishmael's like, Yeah. It's like he does this every ship, you're not special.
SPEAKER_04I I feel like I I gotta hope that uh that's not the case. I gotta hope that Quequest. Yeah, you want to think he's special.
SPEAKER_03Is there, I mean, we we've obviously what what we're alluding to here is the fact that 30 pieces of silver was the amount of money that Judas Iscariot was offered and took to betray Christ.
SPEAKER_00It's a charged number. It could have been 10, but it was the famous 30 pieces of silver, yeah.
SPEAKER_03And then of course you get the famous kiss of Judas in the Garden of Gethsemane. So again, we've got a kiss between men, actually, as part of the subtext of this chapter.
SPEAKER_00Amazing.
SPEAKER_04One that betrays Christ, too, as as Ishmael Idolater.
SPEAKER_00While you're at it, do a little betrayal of Christ.
SPEAKER_03Who ordered the betrayal of Christ? You'd make it sound like it's a kind of it's like a platter that's us. It's a cocktail. Yeah, okay. What's in a betrayal of Christ cocktail?
SPEAKER_04Um, it's gotta have some grenadine, it's gotta have some red color.
SPEAKER_00Grenadine, yeah, lovely.
SPEAKER_03A small piece of bread.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's served with those um pretzel bites. All right, we're getting a little away from ourselves, but I like it.
SPEAKER_03But it but that's really wonderful, though. It's it's it's fascinating to think how the theological underpinning of the chapter is also interacting with the queer aesthetics that we're that we're delving into as well.
SPEAKER_04Um I find the the counting very interesting. So a little backstory on uh Tristan when he was in grad school, like one of his big projects was working on uh uh try to figure out how the numeral system in Pure Pecha worked because I had uh two uh a brother and a sister that I worked with who were uh Pure Pecha native speakers and they counted differently. And so I'm very interested in numeral systems. Um and so it was very interesting to me that specifically Queek seems to only be able to count to 50. Um and I was trying to establish whether there's any sort of real-world like analog to this. Um and it's kind of an odd choice in terms of like like a highest numeral, but I was able to find at least one paper that seem that referenced there being like it was like a like a taxonomy of like different highest numbers across different languages, and there was at least one data point where like the highest attested numeral for the language was 50. So it is possible that like uh this isn't like totally uh out of nowhere or like out like beyond like uh what's what's plausible from like a linguistic perspective, though it is kind of a weird choice. Most most languages don't have like 50 as like a highest number. So I thought it was interesting, but uh there it seems like it it's at least semi-plausible. But generally speaking, like that's not a very good uh highest number. Like if you were to like some some different languages, like you know, you have like a word that corresponds to like a fixed, like larger number, like you start counting in 20s or something. Um but 50 as a choice. Uh I've not found any like a numeral system that's like a base 50. It's not the most uh like I guess anthropologically informed choice for Quequeg to have specifically 50.
SPEAKER_03Well, it might just be Ishmael's faulty anthropology because he he's he's making the assumption that Queekweg is counting 50 pages and is then making these noises, these noises of astonishment. I I mean it would be just like Ishmael to sit there and count the number of pages.
SPEAKER_00Honestly, it was just his luck Ishmael was there to watch.
SPEAKER_03Exactly, exactly.
SPEAKER_00He's gonna interpret this.
SPEAKER_03I yeah, I think this is just as much a reflection on Ishmael as it is on Kuiquag.
SPEAKER_04Um how long is Ishmael uh like standing there counting?
SPEAKER_03For him to turn over at least two sets of 50 pages.
SPEAKER_00Come on.
SPEAKER_03It's ages that he's sat there going, okay, right, well, and he's and what's he doing? He's sort of counting along as he's sort of keeping a little tally of okay. 50. And now he's doing the little he's now he's doing the the sort of the the noises again. Yeah um Ishmael, who is also no expert in the way that Kuiqueg communicates or kind of uh at this stage, so who knows whether these this does a what he calls a long-drawn gurgling whistle of astonishment actually holds some kind of significance to to Kuiqueg that that Ishmael has no has no sense of.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. One thing, so it if Ishmael is correct, um, which it's again, it's kind of like a dubious, like largest number to pick, but that would probably uh mean that it's more likely that Kuiqueg is from a non-agricultural society. Um, because like uh typically speaking, you're more likely if you're a hunter-gatherer society not to like bother to develop like numerals above a certain number because it's just kind of not really relevant. You're not like having to keep track of like number of seeds or bushels of whatever. And so, yeah, so there might be some uh indication. We also get, like, interestingly enough, uh, on a related note, um, in terms of biographical information about Quequeg, we got that he's uh 20,000 miles from home by way of Cape Horn, that is. Um, which I was trying to plot out, like, you know, if that if we were to take that literally, like where could he like be located in? And that kind of puts you pretty far uh uh west in the Pacific, um, like kind of around Indones-ish, is like kind of the range of places that would kind of make sense if we're to take it literally. But it was it was kind of a fun little project for me to try to figure out like uh it it becomes more difficult to figure out how far things are away from each other when you have to like factor in going uh by Cape Horn. You can't exactly just plug that into Google Maps, yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_03Add a stop on your route on Apple Maps, Cape Horn, 20,000 miles then off to the west.
SPEAKER_04And the last uh uh uh biographical note is we we get specifically uh uh phrenological assessment of Quequeg's head, which we haven't touched on yet. Uh specifically, that he looks like like George Washington cannibalistically developed. What do we think of that one?
SPEAKER_03This has got to be satirical, hasn't it? This has got to be Melville.
SPEAKER_00I believe, like, yes. I can't tell you where I've read this, but I believe, yeah, this is a moment where we're we're supposed to be like, we're taking this a bit far. And this, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Surely, surely this is Melville poking fun at the craze for phrenology that was that was happening in the 19th century. Phrenology for those who are uninitiated, um, was the it's it's it's a comp it's a pseudoscience. It's complete, it's all it's complete bunkum. Let me say that at the right at the top of this little precy. Um it's it's supposedly the ability to read people's personality traits or kind of characteristics by the shapes of their heads. Um it's all nonsense. Um it's deeply rooted also in uh racial uh stereotypes. So if you if you if you have the skull shape and size and kind of form of a typically Western individual, uh that's that was generally perceived as being quite good, and if you didn't, then it was perceived as generally bad. You can see the uh the the way it's being exposed actually in the way that Melville is is laying it out to us here. So it may seem ridiculous, but it reminded me of General Washington's head as seen in the popular busts of him. So it's it's a completely false syllogism, isn't it? Um Washington was a good bloke. Uh Washington had this shaped head, therefore, people with this shaped head must be good blokes blokes. No, it's clearly not true. And I don't know the the the way that that Melvin is laying it out here is is is surely leading us to believe that we can't take it in any way seriously.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, this is very like judge a book by its cover uh esque. Not to to uh cheapen, yeah, exactly what you just said. It's it's it's that level of critical thinking, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and it's significant that this what seems to me like complete debunking of phrenology follows hard upon what I think is actually a wonderfully profound um series of observations actually about Queequake's interiority. You cannot hide the soul. Through all his unearthly tattooings, I thought I saw the traces of a simple, honest heart. And in his large, deep eyes, fiery black and bold, there seem tokens of a spirit that would dare a thousand devils. But let me tell you about phrenology.
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes. He exactly like you just said, he gives us things that he could really only give us if he's like, I've spent time with this person. Yes. Here's what he is like, with this most like TikTok level of like, well, you can tell by the forehead that he's noble. This is coming back, by the way, and we need to fight this with all of our might. But yeah, this idea that I think it's supposed to read like we ramp up it to the level of absurdity, and then we kind of stay with this sort of like troubling, you know, the noble savage trope.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, with Melville seems to be both like in charge of in the sense that he's making fun of it, and then also he does seem to just sincerely say it. But with our eyes, we can sort of realize that we needn't throw the baby out with a bath water just because certainly certain parts of it, you know, that we can we need to be able to see the problem, but then we can kind of work with it. I think in an interesting way, I was thinking, I think this shows up a lot in a book that I love, which is Dracula. A lot of the characters there are like, time out. Here's what this person's skull looks like. And we're like, Abraham, what's going on here? So, kind of like Freud, you want to be like, this is not science, but it is useful as a tool that the author is giving us to understand what they're trying to say. So I like, I know that that's not real, but because this is just another way you're telling me to try to understand the narrator and the thing that they're talking about. So we can both kind of have our cake and eat it too a little bit with this thing, like this goofy George Washington skull. And we're like, well, now I understand that he has a noble bearing, but also that we're mayor we can also see that we're trying to like deconstruct the ways that we assume Western ideals on a non-Western body, which is troublesome.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it certainly is.
SPEAKER_04One thing I will say is that of the like people's heads that I can most readily like kind of picture in my mind, George Washington has a very distinctive head. Like, I think like almost anybody else, it'd be very difficult for me to imagine like what that sloping forehead looked like, except for George Washington. What his head looks like is like ingrained in my brain, I think, from looking at so many quarters.
SPEAKER_03Um so it's I was I was in the presence, I was in the presence of a huge bust of Washington not so long ago when I was at Sulgrave Manor, which was the residence or at least one of the residences of I think Washington's great-grandparents. Okay. And it's and it's this bizarre, it's out in the middle of absolutely nowhere. And uh and it's just this little pocket of everything to do with Washington. Amazing just out in the sticks in the UK and outside they have this big sculpture that was um that was commissioned for the for his bicentenary. It's called Bicentennial Washington. And so, yeah, I I too, Tristan, at the minute, have a because I was there quite recently, have a very, very strong sense of what his 3D head looks like.
SPEAKER_00Excellent. That's excellent. George Washington in England is a very interesting sort of I don't think he never did he ever come to the UK? I don't think I don't think he ever left this what we would call the states. Um, I think there's a statue of him, as I recall from my visit next to I think the National Gallery in London, that like Trafalgar Square. Is that what it is with the lions and the Yes, that's right. I think he's there's a full body of him, and I think the dirt he's standing on is from the States. But I was like, George, wait a second, my president? I was like, what are we doing here? I'm here to see some paintings, but yeah, that's funny. So in any case, yeah, we all like you've said, like that's a a skull we can all bring to mind. Every reader would be like, Oh yes, Washington, of course.
SPEAKER_03So is so So are we suggesting then this is actually quite a a covert way of giving us quite a specific physical description of Queequeg?
SPEAKER_00I think it must be both.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Obviously, I'm not somebody who subscribes to phrenology, but one thing that I do uh one of my kind of uh folk beliefs or whatever, uh, that we do get like just before the phrenological assessment is that like you can tell a lot about somebody from like looking into their eyes, or like basically like if you look somebody in the eyes, you can kind of see like whether they got a lot going on behind those eyes or not. And I think that like Ishmael very specifically gets like uh that peek into uh Kuiqueg's soul that he has from the eyes. And specifically, uh, we get the language of uh he looked like a man who had never cringed and never had a creditor, which I think is one of my favorites. That's my favorite line.
SPEAKER_00Yes, that's so good. That's so good. I wish it was written parallel, but it's not, but it's still it's a good one.
SPEAKER_04How would you how would you uh what's uh Meg's uh editing notes?
SPEAKER_00If it was parallel, it would say he looked like a man who had never cringed and had never had a creditor, instead he he flips it around, which would take a point off of his SAT score, but it's still a really it's a banger, that's a banger line. I wish I had never cringed and had never had a creditor, but I unfortunately I've done both uh many times. So I'm not as good a man.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, cringe, I think, is an interesting specific part of it. And I think like yeah, I went on a little bit of a tangent, like thinking about like specifically like what cringing is like, or like what like what what what it means that Quequeg has never cringed.
SPEAKER_03Well, I suppose we sort we sort of thinking of cringing and bowing as gestures of subservience for a start. Yeah. So that would fit in interestingly with a chapter that we'll talk about soon, biographical, where we learn a little bit about Quequeg's origins and the the the unlikelihood, bearing in mind those origins that he would ever have to cringe or bow or be subservient to anybody. Uh bearing in mind what we've also been saying about affective openness in this chapter, I'd also say that a cringe is quite it's it's posturally, it's very closed. And what we see in Quequeg actually is somebody who is physically, and it turns out, affectively very, very open, very generous, very, very receptive to experience, but also to other people.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. And I think there's an element of like social embarrassment, yeah. Like uh like a a social self-consciousness that I think that Ishmael's or like the the lack thereof that Ishmael is like attracted to, or like the perceived lack thereof in uh Quequak, like the sort of like uh genuineness that's not like self-analyzing, or like a like uh what's the word?
SPEAKER_00Like self-consciousness?
SPEAKER_04Self-consciousness, which I think like, you know, I I I think you know, one of the things we've been saying is like uh that it seems like Quequak has a lot more agency or a lot more like thought about like what he's doing and why he's doing it than sometimes I think Ishmael like gives him credit for. Um but I think the Ishmael is uh attracted this idea of like existing without that sort of self-consciousness that seems like so endemic. I think like that cringingness.
SPEAKER_03And we've already seen plenty of that, haven't we? He he absolutely owns everything that he does. This is a man who is completely unabashed uh when it comes to harpooning beefsteaks at breakfast, shaving with the with the tip of his harpoon. This guy absolutely dances to his own tune and is completely unapologetic about it. Of course, he doesn't cringe.
SPEAKER_00No, yeah, never.
SPEAKER_04And one last thing that I definitely wanted to uh to touch on as like kind of a recurring thread that we've had. Um I'm always interested when we have uh phantom or like phantoms come up within this, um, like we get in the very first chapter, and as we got in the counterpane, where we have this first encounter, like the the phantom arm and like the the memory from childhood that we get. But it's uh we get specifically before uh the strange feelings, um, the evening shades and phantoms gathering around the casements and peering in upon a silent, solitary twain. Um and I think like the the specific recurring of the phantom in this moment of like kind of real, sort of like queer realization is like kind of it it's useful to have that word there. Because I feel like that's like a through line through a lot of like the the queer self-development of Ishmael is like this phantom presence that accompanies it or that seems to bespeak something like repressed about Ishmael that uh comes up in these moments.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's great, Tristan. I think it will be a really fascinating word to track throughout the text as it relates to the the queer aesthetics of of Moby Dick, but also to Moby Dick himself, the whale, yes, uh, who is that grand hooded phantom, right, alluded to uh at the at the end of Loomings. And we'll have ample opportunity, I think, to talk about the whale as in some way a kind of queer-coded animal in this text as a whole. So, yeah, it's again talking about the ways in which different things are knitted together um thematically and and and narratively. I think that's going to be a really fascinating word to track. And I think it it it a really wonderful kind of aspect of it, yeah, comes out here. It's a it's a wonderful little sort of knot on the line in terms of the yeah, the the instances where it comes up.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, one thing we've not done, which I think like good on us, but like I think it's relevant here, is like the the the classic Moby Dick Dick joke, right? Um, and like specifically thinking about uh like the like the queer aspects of the way it's like one of the things I think is so interesting is that like the like phallic associations of that specific word, like dick in the title of this book, don't appear to have been like that that that's not like an association that is uh like historically present at that time. That's a later development, but I think it is such an interesting thing.
SPEAKER_00We didn't say dick for dicks. Someone didn't know. I don't believe so. That's it. We don't need it that all right, we can fuss with this later.
SPEAKER_04I've already I've I've done that, I've done that etymology search.
SPEAKER_00You've been on OED.com or whatever. All right. That's a that would have surprised me.
SPEAKER_03I would have I I hope you've cleared your search history, Tristan.
SPEAKER_04Never it all comes out in the end. No, uh fact check me, please do. Um I but I believe it's not like I think that's a later development um from my like because I've I've looked up like the like that etymology because of this question. But it's so interesting like that there is this through line. It seems like to sort of almost like uh ahistorically or in some kind of like almost time traveling sort of way, like anticipate what will become like that phallic uh or like become like a much more obvious phallic uh association between the whale in you know the male member.
SPEAKER_03Apparently it's been it's the uh Dick as penis has been current since the 1550s. Has it?
SPEAKER_00That's what OED.com says.
SPEAKER_03It is what OED.com says, suggests.
SPEAKER_00It's the mid-1500s. I yes, I hold on.
SPEAKER_03I might get I might be getting slightly con contrasting info here. So the name Dick as a shortening for Richard dates back to the middle of the 16th century. But then I'm getting the earliest documented use of dictamine penis appeared in British army slang around the eighteen nineties.
SPEAKER_04So it could be it's possible that that that's it it actually predates that in the spoken language. It's possible. But yeah, like the first attestation of it as that, yeah, like I'm getting the same thing as like uh 1891 in print. Um so it it could it could have been current, like it's not that weird if it's like in spoken language, you know, a couple decades before that. Um I guess that'd be 40 years before that. But yeah, it it it's it's not entirely clear. So it could have been.
SPEAKER_03Melville doesn't need it anyway because he's gonna do a whole chapter about the whale's penis, and it's called the cassock. Uh and a guy wears a whale penis like a poncho. Uh so he doesn't he doesn't need stay tuned, listeners, for that episode.
SPEAKER_00Don't go anywhere. We'll be right back.
SPEAKER_03Love it. You've been listening to the Pequod Pod with Tristan Bavell Marquise, Meg Fansher, and Johnny Wiles. Our music is by Lost in the Loop with sound engineering by Lauren Aiton. The show's artwork is by Delaney Garrett, and Tristan is on the Synths. We want to say a big thank you to all of our supporters on Patreon. You can join them over at patreon.com forward slash pequod pod for bonus content and for opportunities to help us keep the show running in ship-shaped condition. Ratings and reviews also really help us out, so if you enjoy the show, please do express your thoughts and metaphysical yearnings in the review section wherever you're listening to the show. Tell your friends, tell your foes, tell the white whale on whom you're monomaniacally urged to be revenged. It all helps.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Age of Napoleon Podcast
Everett Rummage