PequodPod
The podcast on the wonder-world of Herman Melville. We're currently reading Moby-Dick and talking about each chapter. We also enjoy and discuss Melville's other works such as Typee, Omoo, Mardi, Redburn, Whitejacket, Pierre, Bartleby, Benito Cereno, The Confidence-Man, Billy Budd, and more!
Support the show: www.patreon.com/PequodPod
PequodPod
The Biblical Sources of Moby-Dick with Dr. Jonathan A. Cook
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Welcome to PequodPod! The podcast on the wonder-world of Herman Melville.
In this episode, we interview our special guest Dr. Jonathan A. Cook about the biblical sources of Moby-Dick. Dr. Cook is the author of Inscrutable Malice: Theodicy, Eschatology, and the Biblical Sources of Moby-Dick and many other fascinating articles on Melville's oeuvre. We talk Jonah & Job, Peleg & peroration, eschatology & Ecclesiastes. Hop on in 'cause we're going to Sunday school!
If you enjoy the show, please consider helping defray the costs of making the show by joining us on Patreon at patreon.com/PequodPod
Please also consider telling a friend about the show. Word of mouth is the best way to spread the word about PequodPod, and it helps us tremendously.
Look here yet again. A little lower layer. All visible objects, man, are but postboard masks. But in each event, in the living act of the undoubted deed, there. Some unknown but still reasoning thing puts forth the mouldings of its features from behind the unreasoning mask. If man will strike, strike through the mask. How can the prisoner reach outside except by thrusting through the wall? To me, the white whale is that wall stuff near to me. Sometimes I think there's naught beyond. But it's enough. He tasks me. I see in him outrageous strength with an inscrutable malice sinewing it. That inscrutable thing is chiefly what I hate. And be the white whale agent or be the white whale principal, I will wreak that hate upon him. Talk not to me of blasphemy, man. I fight for something for insulting me.
SPEAKER_02Today we've got a fantastic uh special guest. We've got Dr. Jonathan A. Cook, who is a literary scholar, educator, and musician, uh currently living in uh is it still Northern Virginia?
SPEAKER_04No, I'm in Charlottesville now, where Poe went to school, where a lot of other uh uh you know notable literary people went to school as well.
SPEAKER_02So wonderful. You've taught literature and writing uh for uh uh decades now. Um and uh you're you're very interested in Harmon Melville, which is why we've got you here. And you wrote um a really interesting book called Uh Inscrutable Malice, uh Theodicy, uh Eschatology in the Biblical Sources of Moby Dick. Um and I also found this interesting. Uh so you you also are a musician, and so you uh you play guitar and mandolin. Would you be uh willing to please uh explain uh what theodicy and uh eschatology mean for our audience?
SPEAKER_04Okay. Yeah, um so these are really interesting, important terms for anyone who's interested in religion. And uh I mean they sound very uh sort of forbidding, but you know, theodicy just means the justice of God. And it's the word comes from Leibniz's book that he wrote early 18th century, uh trying to explain why everything that God does has a reason and a purpose. And but it's actually the concept is very much integral to the Bible, uh, you know, Old and New Testament. Um so I have a very strong focus on the book of Job in my book and all the resonances that that book has in Moby Dick. And Job is in fact the most persuasive and beautifully written theodicy in the Old Testament. In fact, it's a classic of theodicy in terms of justifying God's goodness or his power, just uh sort of undermining the fact that humans, no matter how much we question the role of good and evil in the world, is that uh, you know, God is there uh as a guarantor that everything is happening on his plan. So uh no matter how much we might question the justice of terrible things happening in our lives, which I think we can all relate to today, uh there is a plan, right? And that's the Odyssey. So eschatology, eschatos in Greek just means the last. So it's the logos of last things, meaning uh what happens at the end of human life and at the end of human history. And of course, in the New Testament, the book of Revelation is the chief document of Christian eschatology describing the end times, right? We all know that. We all know the story of you know the second coming and that kind of thing. So, but the Old Testament has eschatological passages. In fact, a lot of the book of Revelation is based on passages from the Old Testament, uh, because they were just recycling the same imagery, same ideas, as you know, this final crisis in history when God intervenes to rectify the screw-ups that human beings have created in the world. So both con uh both the Odyssey and eschatology relate to justice happening in the world, either uh in this life or in the next life. Because we all know that in Christianity, if you're good, you go to heaven no matter how much you've suffered. Yeah. So there's a rectification of the inequalities of life in the afterlife.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. So I think uh that's an important point to touch on. Uh basically, like, if God is good, why is the world clearly not does not seem to be good, basically, or why does it seem so uh like why does evil uh exist, or like uh why is it allowed to exist? But yeah, thinking about like the period of like second temple Judaism, or like uh thinking about when you have uh foreign oppressors who are specifically punishing people for following the law. Like how do you reckon with that? Like how does that like how can that be uh allowable by God?
SPEAKER_04That's how the book of Daniel was written, right? Uh you know, Antioches, Epiphanes, uh 167 BC, he's invaded Jerusalem. He's he's gonna put uh make the the Jews eat pork and put a statue of himself in the temple. And the book of Daniel, uh, which is ostensibly uh pretends to be about the prophet Daniel during the Babylonian captivity in the 6th century, but it's really about uh Israel or Jerusalem in uh the 160s when this uh descendant of one of Alexander the Great's generals is there uh trying to eliminate Judaism, right, as a sect. So their their idea is that, in fact, that's really when the idea of the afterlife emerged in in Judaism, because the idea was that the people who were defending the faith at that point would end up as stars in heaven. So there's this kind of implication that they have this immortal life as opposed to going to Sheol, which is the the ancient Jewish idea of hell, which is is kind of a nebulous underworld, doesn't really involve punishment. Um yeah, I think you're right.
SPEAKER_02Like uh if God rewards people for being just and they're punished for their like being just and there's no afterlife, then God basically like loses his quality of uh being merciful or being just. And so like you have to come up with a His brand is damaged.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. So yeah, I mean, and and my argument in the book is that Bowie Dick is is really about a confrontation with evil, right? The evil of the white whale. Ahab is this mad captain who who extrapolates his own injuries into this cosmic scheme of revenge, right? He wants and he figures that he's already a bit of a religious rebel, and then he eventually identifies this terrible wound that he receives that he can't explain in other any other way as a punishment that he's getting from God that he didn't deserve.
SPEAKER_02So in thinking about the biblical sources of Moby Dick, um, like for our audience, could you highlight some of the parts of the Bible that you view as being uh most helpful in understanding the text or most uh relevant or like most widely used in the text of Moby Dick?
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Well, first of all, the book of Job. I mean, you really I in my study, I really do a lot of quoting from Job and just showing all the parallelisms between Ahab and even Ishmael, because I I argue that even Ishmael is a kind of anti-Job. You know, he's he's kind of resilient, he takes his punches and he and then he uh he kind of realizes that the God might just be some old joker that he can't really question anything about. So anyway, you got to know the book of Job, you gotta know Genesis, especially the first few chapters of Genesis. You know, the first chapter, of course, the creation, uh, because the imagery there is key. You know, when God created the great whales as the first great creatures, you know, the word whale in the Bible is actually a Hebrew word tanim, which is is could be more like of a sea monster or dragon. So whale is really an arbitrary term, but of course that word entered the English language, and so that became a kind of uh archetypal idea that, you know, the whale is some kind of prized animal creation of God. And uh parts of Isaiah, um, Ezekiel, Jeremiah, you know, they're long, they're the major prophets, those are long books, but intermittently they're passages that Melville is is is quoting or is familiar with. So those are the main ones. The New Testament, of course, you have to know the four gospels and uh the two the Pauline letters, especially First and Second Corinthians, because Melville is also quoting that, because as I argue in my book, Mel uh Ishmael is kind of um a creator of secular sermons based on Pauline texts in a lot of his Cetology. He's he's he's really kind of he's drawing on these, making these lessons out of the whales anatomy, which often are adaptations of Pauline statements uh in in Paul's letters. And of course, you have to know the book of Revelation well. And I mean, I think most people know that by osmosis because our culture is so permeated with it. We we live in an apocalyptic culture. But anyway, it's good to give that a read just to get all those uh you know those nasty creatures straight, you know, the Antichrist and the devil and the false prophet and the man of sin and beast from the sea, beast from the land, all these beasts that emerge in that book. It's a fascinating gallery of uh monsters.
SPEAKER_02We start with Ishmael. What's the significance of that choice, do you think?
SPEAKER_04Uh, you know, he was the child of Abraham and his concubine who could not inherit uh the mantle of the family lineage. And so I think as you mentioned in one of your first podcasts, he's he's the rejected son because he's not at the legitimate birth. You know, um Abraham's wife Sarah was too old to have a child, so uh his concubine had the child. But then when Sarah gave birth to Isaac, uh Ishmael was uh undesirable presence. So he went out with his mom into the desert, and they were really struggling. And uh his mother says, you know, don't let my child die. And as a result, God intervenes. So the name Ishmael, I think, means God hears, uh, so that Ishmael was saved, and he supposedly became the progenitor of all the Arab neighbors of the Israelites, right? The Semitic, other Semitic tribes. So he had some kind of uh glorious lineage, but as a as a kind of an exiled figure. Um so he's an outcast, you know. There are other characters. He was, you know, Ishmael, when Mel was writing, everyone recognized Ishmael as the archetypal outcast from his from his culture. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Perfect. Okay, what about Ahab?
SPEAKER_04So Ahab, yeah, he's he's uh Ahab offended God more than any other um Hebrew king because he he made an alliance with a Canaanite woman, Jezebel, and brought in the worship of Baal, who was the kind of alternative archetypal idol uh of the time, you know, because Israel was kind of fighting a competition with Baal, because they Baal was sort of almost the spiritual brother of Yahweh, you know, the god of the Jews was really very heavily influenced by Baal as a as a god of the a thunder god, you know, a sky god. And so uh they really they really looked down on the the Baalites, and so Ahab had allowed all these foreign um practices to infiltrate into Israel, and God you know was really mad according to the prophets. You know, his um Elijah was his main opponent. Of course, Elijah shows up in Moby Dick as the kind of wharf rat who warns uh Ishmael and Quequeg away from the uh Pequod, you know, gives him a lowdown about how of course he's he's not telling him directly, he's being oblique the way prophets always are supposed to be. So anyway, Ahab was the was the worst king in Israelite history. Of course, Israel history is is all written to show who did good things and who did bad things because it all climaxed in the Babylonian captivity, captivity 586. You know, Babylonians came and took over Israel and in two waves and eventually brought all the upper class people back to their culture. They left some of the Hebrews back in Israel, but the most of the upper class and the important people were in exile for the next hundred years or so. So Israelite history is all pointing towards you know who messed up uh the relationship with God so that it was it led to the total destruction of the of the um of the Israelite state. Um actually it was Judah at the time. Israel, the northern kingdom, had already been eliminated in about 772, I think it was. But there was still Judah, which is where Jerusalem is. So that's that's who Ahab is.
SPEAKER_02Wonderful. Um so we touched on him uh for a second there, but could what about Elijah? Can you tell us a little bit more about Elijah?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, Elijah was Ahab's enemy. Ahab really had it out for him. He had Elijah had to escape for his life, and so he he spent some time in the desert and uh away from Ahab, but he constantly was he was his opponent and um you know condemned him for everything he did, including the fact that Ahab took over this uh this uh vineyard of a commoner, um Naboth his name was, and it was uh uh an unjust condemnation of this innocent man because Ahab supposedly wanted his property. Uh it could have people uh who write on this say maybe his wife Jezebel or Jezebel Jezebel might have been influential in this, but um Elijah condemned Ahab, of course, for this terrible miscarriage of justice and killing this innocent Israelite. So first to last, he was uh Ahab's major prophetic opponent. And of course, Ahab, you know, was killed uh in his battle with the Assyrians at Ramoth Gilead, which was a battle uh he'd already fought against this enemy, but in this battle he um he was prophesied to be killed uh and he ignored the warnings and he went out and he was killed by an arrow. And the prophecy was that you know dogs would lick the blood off his chariot, which indeed what happened, he was shot, and he bled into his chariot, went back, and the dogs you know cleaned it up for him. So everything that Elijah said, you know, happen was was true, and uh Ahab had a you know tragic fate for his for his hubris, right? He's the he's the archetypal figure of hubris in the Old Testament.
SPEAKER_02Wonderful. Um and then what about uh Bildad and Peleg?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, Bildad Peleg. Uh so Bildad is one of Job's comforters. Job had three comforters. It's not a it's not the comforter you sleep with at night, but these are comforters that try to give Job consolation for the tra the tragedies that took place in his life when his children were killed, his his wealth was taken away, and he was tortured with this terrible skin disease. Uh, so he was physically miserable and desolate, and he just wanted to die. And his three friends came along and said, Hey, can we help out? Uh, tell us about it. And of course, they didn't really help him because they said, Job, you must have done something wrong, or one of your kids did something. Because that doesn't, God doesn't punish people for no reason. So they just over and over, they're driving this home. And you know, Job is going crazy saying, No, I didn't do anything wrong. This was just arbitrary. I mean, God is hurting me for no reason. Um, so that's Bill. That Pelag is is just uh not a very important Old Testament character, and his name, I guess, means division. Uh, but they're, you know, they have these Old Testament names. And of course, on uh, you know, Nantucket, the the community was very much a Quaker community, right? Uh these are people with Old Testament names because the Quakers in the mainly in the 18th century and into the 19th gave tons of their children qu uh Old Testament names. So you really you find a huge gallery of very some very familiar Old Testament and some not so familiar names, which uh I mentioned in my book, you know. Um so the the the the the friends, the Quakers were responsible for those names.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, do you think there's any uh particular meaning intended with those two choices of names for those two characters?
SPEAKER_04Well, Bill Dad, of course, he's a kind of a religious hypocrite because he wants to cheapen uh the salary that uh he's paying uh Ishmael, you know, to this tiny portion of the voyage. So I mean it kind of gives you a preview of the Job theme that's gonna erupt because they talk about uh who uh Ahab is before Ishmael signs on. They do a little character sketch of who he is, and it sounds very much like a Job in character because he's you know, he's good but he's bad, and he's got this very, very, you know, he's eloquent, but he's often silent. So it's this very interesting paradoxical identity. So Bill throwing out a uh a name from Job really gives you a preview of that. Now, Peleg, I'm not really sure why he is in there, but he's just he's just another you know, Old Testament figure, and he's they they really have a kind of um good cop, bad cop uh relationship that's that's part of the comedy of the early chapters of the book that's wonderful to read, you know.
SPEAKER_02Wonderful. Okay, um, so by the time this comes out, we'll be just coming off of uh Father Mapple's sermon. Um what insights can you give us into this sermon and then also uh like the the source material for it, the book of Jonah?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, well, I was you know, I was looking over this part of the book, and I I just wanted to I don't know if previously anyone has mentioned the fact that uh Father Mapple is almost everyone agrees that he's based on this guy, Edward Taylor, who was a well-known uh his dates are 1793 to 1871. Um so he had this place in Boston called the Seaman's Chapel in uh in the north end of Boston, and he was a famous sailor preacher because he he only became literate at the age of 20. He was actually born in Richmond, Virginia. But he went to sea as a teenager and he was uh I think he was on mainly merchant vessels, but after a while he uh was uh converted and became a Methodist preacher, which had kind of looser uh standards for ordination, right? So he became a itinerant Methodist in uh New England in the 1820s. I think he got his pulpit in the early 1830s in in Boston. Um, but he was famous because of his eloquence, and people, all kinds of people would go to hear him preach because he just had this incredible style of mixing all these kind of pungent sailor uh terms. And uh basically when you get went to his chapel, you were like on his ship, right? And he was the captain. His his his sermons were he really kind of made them up as he went along. I mean, he'd probably use a text just like every sermon is supposed to begin with a biblical text, right? But he was his style was very much improvisational. And we have these testimonies from Emerson and Whitman and Harriet Martineau, Dickens even heard him preach in the early 1840s. Melville almost certainly heard him on his trip to Boston in 1849. Early 1849, he was there to uh be by with his wife when she gave birth to their first son because her father lived in Boston, uh Lemuel Shaw. And so that he stayed up in Boston for a couple of months, and that Church would not have been far away for him to go and hear Father Father Taylor. So Father Taylor uh totally matches uh Father Maple. And even in terms of the painting in uh in Moby Dick uh matches the painting almost the same in uh Father Taylor's chapel uh because it was a picture of a ship on a Lee shore, uh, you know, which is where the wind is blowing, where you're at risk of having a wreck. And um so both of them are almost identical uh pictures in the background, also in terms of the pulpit having this ship-like pulpit. And Father Taylor's chapel was not that big. So when he started preaching, he would tell everyone to sort of gather in the center, you know, to close up ranks. And he'd use this this kind of shipboard terminology the same way that Father Maple says, you know, everyone's got a you hear these shuffles of midships, midships. So exactly the same thing done. And the thing about Father Taylor in Boston was he would he pref he had a preference for uh sailor parishioners, right? So the sailors were all allowed to sit in the middle, the visitors were all on the side, right? So they they didn't get the privileged seats. So anyway, you know, Father Taylor was a uh he was a character, he was well known. Unfortunately, not many, only the only evidence of his sermons are in people's recollections. He did not publish any books of sermons, which makes sense because you know a lot of them were just done on the fly. Um so what is interesting about the sermon, too, it's based on, you know, it's a traditional sermon because it has a text. And uh after a text, you get the exposition, which means telling the uh congregation what the biblical text, what kind of moral message is supposed to convey. Then you have what's called the application, which is uh taking situations from real life and describing how the message uh applies to that situation, and then you have the the uh peroration or exhortation at the end, which is a final uh attempt to tell everyone this is what you should go out and do after you hear me talking about this, right? So you you have this clear structure in the sermon, and it's interesting to note that Melville's father, uh, you know, his grandfather, in fact, Thomas Melville, went to Princeton. He he was the uh descendant of a long line of Scottish uh ministers from the Kirk in Scotland, right? So Melville's grandfather might have become a minister if the political situation at the time hadn't pushed him into joining the revolutionary forces in Boston because he was actually attended the the Tea Party uh as an Indian. He dressed up as an Indian and the Melville family had a container of tea that supposedly they that the grandfather saved from that experience. So the grandfather was quite a he was a revolutionary war hero, not quite as famous as Melville's mother's father, right? Um General Peter Gansavort, right? He had a more prominent, more prominent role in the revolution, but Thomas Melville Sr. also uh distinguished himself as a Revolutionary War hero.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so thinking about like uh um specifically like how the book of Jonah is talked about in the sermon, but is there anything you find interesting? Um one of the things uh like the book of Johnic, it's in the Moby Dick itself, it's mentioned as being like uh, you know, like four sh like a four short yarns or whatever uh Father Maple says. It's a bit it's a very short book.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_02Um and one of the things I find interesting is like uh the level of like detail and color that Father Maple gives it. Like his uh his version of it is like uh kind of more enfleshed or like uh bigger in a sense or like more cinematic than like what's actually present in the book itself. I'm curious if you uh find anything interesting about the decisions made and like this retelling of Jana, or like to what extent you view it as uh um significant to the the the goals of the book as a whole.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, well, uh in general, I mean the sermon is there, Father Michael's there to to really establish a moral framework for what the whole society was supposed to be founded on, you know, Christian values, which is submit yourself to God. You're you you have no right to go against what uh the Bible tells you to do. I mean, there's definitely a structure of authority there that really kind of is very different when you get to see with Ahab, right? So you're kind of inverting the traditional Christian structures that are announced there of you know submission to God. Uh so it's really a a chance to sort of frame the religious foundation for the book that the culture maintains and that Melville will uh implicitly be challenging with with his with his story. Now it's uh what I love about this sermon is it it really contemporizes the book. The other thing is this this is you only get the first half of Jonah. So the second half is when he goes and agrees to preach against the Nineveh, right? And that is a that is really kind of a farcical story because Jonah gets there, and the Nineveh's non-Hebrew peoples have already submitted to God's, and he can't, so he's pissed off that he was afraid to go preach against the Ninevites because he thought he was going to get a lot of flack. And and and then when he actually went there, he didn't get there, wasn't any problem. They all said, okay, you know, we submit to God. So Jonah, he uh he kind of pouts, and God creates this fig, fig vine, fig, fig bush to to shelter him. So it ends up as kind of a farcical uh satire on the character of this disgruntled prophet. So, you know, it's it's one of these bizarre books of the Bible. I mean, there's a study of uh of Jonah that, you know, four strange books of the Bible, uh a biblical scholar, and this is definitely one of them. Um but it, you know, it's basically a wonderful fairy tale uh that based on a myth of a monster, you know, being swallowed by a monster is is not unusual as a as a fairy tale motif.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and thinking about like uh the this sermon as sort of foreshadowing for the book, because uh uh it's probably the most prominent whale uh of the Old Testament, I would say. I mean, like you get like uh there's the whale in Job, you've got the great whales in Genesis, but probably like the story people most immediately associate with a whale. Um yeah, right.
SPEAKER_04And the irony is there's no whale word used in in the book of Jonah. It's it's he's a great fish, you know, he's called the great fish, and he's assumed to be a whale. And in Melville, in in Father Mapple's sermon, he had the whale has teeth. So it has to be a sperm whale.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_04Of course, the sperm whale has a very narrow throat, very so there's no way that a human could be swallowed by a sperm whale. Um maybe a right whale, which has a bigger mouth. So the whole thing is just very improbable, but it all makes sense as a moral fable, you know.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, one of the things that I find really interesting about the end of Father Mapple's sermon, uh, and I'll read it here, um, and eternal delight and deliciousness will be his, who coming to lay him down, can say with his final breath, O Father, chiefly known to be by thy rod, mortal or immortal, here I die. I have striven to be thine more than to be this world's or mine own. Yet this is nothing. I leave eternity to thee, for what is man that he should live out the lifetime of his God? Now, which to me is like an interesting thing for like a like a Christian preacher to be like preaching, which is basically saying that, you know, uh kind of forget about the afterlife in a sense, or like a like a lack of care about the idea of uh uh living on for eternity, which for a lot of people that uh within um Christianity, that's like the kind of the whole thing, is like uh afterlife.
SPEAKER_04It is peculiar. It's just I think the ultimate message is submit yourself. I mean, this is this is uh sort of the basis of Calvinism, which is the the you know depravity of man and the and the omnipotence and righteousness of God. So the idea is that you know you're nothing compared to God. To me, it just ties in with that insistence on you know diminishing human uh importance in the world. Although, you know, rereading this chapter, I was struck when you think of the end of the exhortation in the sermon, it it seems as though uh uh could have been sort of saying, This is what uh Ishmael is gonna be doing. He's gonna be doing being this fearless prophet of truth against all the powers of the world, right? So he's gonna tell the truth no matter what the consequences are. But Ishmael really doesn't face that issue so much as intensely. And I'm thinking that you know it's it's Ahab who is seeking to find all sin, you know, even if it comes under the robes of senators and judges, right? You've got to kill all the sin off in the world, right? So Ahab is the one who's accusing God of being a sinner because God has to be evil for doing the things that he that he the way that he runs the world, right? He's he creates these horrible tragedies. Uh you know, Ahab when he's uh you know when he's talking to the uh the the right whale's head hanging on the ship, he goes over all these horrible things that happen in the world where there's no consequences. He's like, why does this happen? All these terrible things. And of course he has his own injury. So in an oddly perverse way, a lot a little bit of Macple's message about being fearless in the exploration of sin could carry over to Ahab himself, who's the archetypal sinner for challenging God.
SPEAKER_02To me, even like Pierre is the one who like seems to take this message to heart, or like that seems like the book that like really in investigates that aspect of it. Like uh like the line here, woe to him whose good name is more to him than goodness, and like what it actually means to like try to live like that. And in Pierre's case, it means like kind of the total destruction of everything to try to actually live like kind of a Christian life.
SPEAKER_04Yes, yes, and I I love Pierre. Unlike a lot of people who who can't stand Pierre because of its overwrought language, I'm a huge fan of Pierre. I think it's the perfect match for Moby Dick because uh Pierre is really uh exploration of the fulfillment of New Testament values in America. Um and uh because we have a hero who tried to make himself into a second Christ figure doing all these wonderful things, preserving his father's memory, and he totally you know screws everyone over, screws himself. Lots of bodies at the end of the book. But uh, you know, just as Moby Dick is really this deep exploration of the Old Testament and the moral framework of that world, you know, premised on the book of Job and the idea of theodicy. So they're really kind of matching halves to this opus that you know is at the heart of Melville's fictional uh project, I think.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. There's a um one of my favorite parts of Pierre, and that I think is kind of the most relevant for like this kind of line of thinking, is the in-text pamphlet, uh chronometricals and horological.
SPEAKER_04Horologicals, yeah, right. Um Plotinus Plin Lynn Lemon's pamphlet, yes. A brilliant uh exposition about uh how uh the world as it exists does not match the idealism that you find in the Sermon on the Mount, say, because really the Sermon on the Mount is the is the ethical heart of Pierre, because Pierre is trying to espouse this super idealistic form of Christianity that that you know is just so hard to practice, in fact, without watering down. Um so Plotinus Plen Lemon is saying there's somehow worldly values and the values of Christianity somehow magically correspond to each other. He doesn't say how. So it's sort of it's sort of like this contradiction is really not a contradiction. And of course, the pamphlet is torn, so he only has the first few pages and he never finds out how Plyn Lemon explains his way out of this paradox. So uh I'm glad that uh there's a fellow Pierre enthusiast here.
SPEAKER_02Uh yeah. No, Pierre is divisive, but the people who like Pierre like Pierre a lot, I think. Oh, yeah. Uh so one of the ideas that I've uh found very captivating lately to think about is the idea of whaling as combining like the two different modes of biblical creation um that we get, like kind of layered in the Old Testament. So there's uh what you're getting from like the the kind of the context of the ancient Near East, and um we will be having in a future episode an Assyriologist on to specifically talk about like the chaos monsters of the ancient Near East. So we'll maybe put a pin in some of that for that later episode, but like uh we we will be touching on that for sure. So you've got like that where like uh creation is the reordering of like the chaotic sea through like the like either the storm god or the sky god slaying the sea and like restructuring it. But then you also have like the later tradition that's also uh present, the uh like God using uh like kind of commands in like a spoken language with the the uh the initial uh command being like uh let there be light. And in in whaling, you have the slaying of the sea monster to create light uh through the whale oil. And so that's been something that's like been in my mind a lot lately.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. So yeah, it's interesting. In the Old Testament, you have this mixed image of Leviathan. Now, Leviathan was the Hebrew adaptation of an older Canaanite creature named Lotan, who was the twisting serpent um in this uh you know, chaos monster mythology. And uh, but uh different parts of the Bible show the whale either as a tame creation of God. I mean, there's Psalm 103 or 4 where uh God is sort of overseeing this happy gallery of whales who were frolicking in the ocean, and then of course the whale is created in the first chapter of Genesis as one of these great creatures who is not malevolent or anything, right? So on the other hand, you have the chaos monster from the book of Job, and God is taunting Job saying, You have really who are you, because you have no possibility of keeping this creature at bay. You know, he just laughs at your uh weapons that you aim at him. So uh uh it's this weird ambiguity about the what this monster. I mean, you have one class of monsters who's a threat to the creation, and then the other class of sea monsters who sort of exist happily within the purview of of the creation. So it seems as though, you know, when Americans were whaling, they're saying, well, you know, most of these whales are not chaos monsters. They're, you know, these creatures who were beated for human exploitation, just like, you know, God told Adam and Eve, or Adam that he, you know, these creatures were for his use, right? They did not exist for themselves, that he could do whatever they wanted with them. So the whale in that view of creation is there to be exploited. I mean, it's not as though America needed some justification from the Bible to go whaling. Of course, that was, you know, as a natural resource, it was the primary way to keep lights going uh from you know the 18th century on. You know, the sperm was burned, you had the the whale oil that was it made the finest candles and also was used in lamps, was used as a lubricant, all these other uses. So a huge amount of whales were being killed up until the 18 through the 1850s. So on the other hand, the the idea of the whale as a chaos monster at the edge of creation, you know, it was not part of the general human uh or American consciousness. Melville kind of drew that out of the book of Job and the Old Testament to make this malevolent whale, because uh only a few whales that actually uh turned against ships and sunk them, like the you were talking about uh the Essex, right, a few episodes ago, right? So the story of the Essex, the Essex, famous story in the 1820, uh a guy, uh a whale actually turning and attacking a whale ship was shocking, right? Because you know, whales were not supposed to be malevolent. The irony is that when Melva published Moby Dick, 1851, he read in the newspaper that uh a ship had been attacked by a whale called the Anne Alexander, one of the few uh examples in the century that he experienced. And he he wrote a letter where he said, you know, I I fear that the you know my my book has some somehow evoked Moby Dick has evoked this whale attack from this whale. He he felt he had some responsibility, you know, in jail for raising the specter of this malevolent whale.
SPEAKER_02So uh you cite the book and character of Job as being particularly important to Moby Dick, uh, and even going so far as to speculate possibly that the the Obi part or like the Obi Moby Dick is coming from Job since uh the historical whale is uh like uh either Mocha or Machia Mocha Dick.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, Mo like the coffee, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Can you give us like a uh the like a general overview for people who don't know Job? We've uh alluded to it a couple of times already, but like uh maybe uh what's the what's the story of Job, and we we can kind of dive into it.
SPEAKER_04All right, so Job, we don't know who the author was, maybe fourth century. It's it's based on a a folk tale. Uh it has two parts. It has a sort of uh a moralistic fairy tale introduction and conclusion, and then it has sort of a middle argument part. Well, Job is a patriarch, he's not specifically Hebrew, um, and he has lots of sheep, he has big family, he has a wife, he's a very well-respected member of the community, he he worships his God. We never know what religion he is, but he's religious. And um one day the Satan, who is uh he's not the New Testament Satan, he's the Satan, who is the word is based on the idea of uh the adversary, right? So he's he's kind of like the prosecuting attorney of God who goes around checking whether people are really religious or not. So he's kind of a the it's sort of a mafia enforcer saying, you know, what about this guy? So Satan, the Satan, goes up to God and says, his heavenly court, and he says, What about Job? You know, is he really as religious as you think he is? And God says, Well, uh, you know, Job is a good guy, but go ahead and see if he is. You can test him. So Satan throws lightning and creates this terrible tragedy, takes all his goods, his house is crushed, his kids are killed. And um Satan is trying to get Job to curse God, right? See, so he's trying to make Job out to be a bad guy. You know, he's he's like a corrupt district attorney who's trying to kind of familiar kind of thing these days, right? Someone in the legal system is trying to show someone is guilty when they're when they're innocent. So Job does not curse God, and Satan goes back and says, Yeah, I'd like to try again, you know, and this time I think I'm gonna physically attack him because all I've done is get rid of his property. Now I'm gonna give him a terrible disease, right? Uh boils, you know, skin disease. So Job uh again he's attacked physically, he's incapacitated. He's there sitting on the ground, you know, scraping his skin with pot shirts, trying to, you know, deal with this terrible eruption, he has. And um he sits down and he starts complaining about the fact that he hasn't done anything wrong. And basically, many, many chapters saying, Why are you doing this to me? It's not fair. If only I had an advocate, if only I could face you in person. And meanwhile, Job have Job's three comforters say, You must have done something wrong. Your kids did something wrong, you're just not facing it, Job. You know, you really uh we can't really understand this unless it's you know you've been at fault. So this goes on for several chapters. Job is very eloquent defending himself. And then uh we have another fourth guy who shows up, Elijah. Who is a young guy who kind of repeats the same argument who just says, you know, you ulsters don't know what's going on, but he pretty much says the same thing. And uh this all goes on until in the about after about 30 some chapters, God appears, uh, a voice from the whirlwind. So you have a he's a storm god who comes there and talks from the whirlwind. So he doesn't actually have a body, he's talking from the wind. And God says, it's it's odd because God says, You've been talking about me truthfully. These other guys don't really know what they're talking about. You're comforters. So God kind of admits that Job has said some true things, and he also but he also puts Job down saying, You don't know this, you don't know how the creation works, you don't know how all these animals survive, this terrible environment, you don't know about this and that and that. And then finally, his last example, chapter 41, you know, he's he's got these two beasts who are these monsters that he's that he's pushed back against. And the second one is the is there's one land monster, Behemoth, who's maybe like a rhinoceros or something. Then there's the sea monster, who's really a combination of uh of like a whale, a dragon. I mean, he's got this fiery breath, he even has fire coming out of his mouth. So the la ultimate insult to Job is that Job can't handle a beast like Leviathan because Leviathan is just overwhelmingly powerful, and Job should just basically keep quiet because uh only God can tame this creature.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. Uh canst thou draw out Leviathan with a hook or his tongue with a cord, which thou lettest out? Yeah, or uh put a hook into his nose or bore his jaw through with a thorn, which I think is like uh is interesting in the context of like wailing, right? Like as a uh like a hubristic enterprise in relation to like uh what God says in Job. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Well, the interesting thing is when Moby Dick finally shows up uh towards the end of the book, chapter 133 or so, a lot of the a lot of the three-day chase uh uh against Moby Dick mimics language from Job. I mean, you have this interesting matchup between assertions, God's assertions about Leviathan and then what actually happens when Ahab is trying to kill Moby Dick. But anyway, just to finish off, Job. George, please. Job is is he kind of his message, uh God's message comes through, and and Job says, You're right, God, you know, I I I submit myself in dust and ashes. So he totally humbles himself. He says, I won't ever question God again. And then God gives him back his children, his goods. And so it's a fairy tale. So he's he's he's rewarded for his submission, and Job kind of lived happily ever after that. So it's a really paradoxical book where you have these incredibly outspoken attacks on the justice of Yahweh, you know, the divinity, in the middle of the book. And then at the end, you have Job saying, You're right, God, uh, I don't really have your capability, so I'm just gonna submit myself.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, um, and uh specifically he like he gets like seven uh new sons and three daughters. The other ones are still dead.
SPEAKER_04Okay, yeah, I forgot. Yeah, they're they're new sons and daughters, but you know, maybe the same sort of uh maybe they look the same. Yeah, yeah, it's a really pathetic. I mean, if you look at it, so it's just a very interesting, odd book. A lot of scholarly work has been done on it, and uh no one can figure out who wrote it or exactly what what the setting of its of its composition was. Uh but it was accepted in the Old Testament um as a genuine you know document. So we have to think that it it really uh pleased a lot of the people putting together the Bible, you know.
SPEAKER_02So yeah, it's interesting to think about like uh because you're right, like it it is it has a weird sort of structure to it, or like it has like this kind of composite structure to it, where like uh there's there is a tension between like the book ends of it versus like the the inner matter of it. And you right um and like thinking about like Job as a character, like the Job of the bookends versus the Job of the inner matter, there's like a there's a difference between, or like they they feel very different. And and uh when thinking of like as you do in your book of Ahab as like this uh like Job-like figure, it's kind of the question of like which Job.
SPEAKER_04It's not the the the the patience of Job, Job, clearly it's no, it's the it's the job who's outraged by his treatment from God, and also the job who's been physically injured, because you know, obviously Ahab loses a leg, he doesn't have a skin disease, but it seems as though Job's skin disease is really kind of incapacitating the same way that Ahab's uh amputated leg was. Um so physical injury and and moral outrage are the the two similar main similarities.
SPEAKER_02So like you you you point to a lot of uh uh parallels between them. You you point to like uh chapter 41, like what uh in Moby Dick is chosen as chapter 41. Um it like matches with uh the chapter 41 in Job. Um what do you think uh drew Melville to uh Job in this way? Do you think it's like the specific uh uh citation of Leviathan as like a uh an element or the the the moral complexity of it?
SPEAKER_04Well, I think Melville was he was he was very much a sort of quiet rebel in his culture. And he you have to really understand the fact that he grew up in a you know in a in a comfortable middle class household that just went to pot, went to hell. Because his father died when he was 12. His father went bankrupt. He had a business as an importer of French fancy goods in New York City. They had a very comfortable life in Manhattan, and then everything fell apart in about 1830. They had to move up to Albany to live with uh Melville's mother's family, the Gansavorts. And um, so Melville had this terrible sense of disinheritance. Uh and uh so you know he suffered when his father died. His brother, his older brother Gansavort took over the family fur business and he ran this fur business in Albany in the mid-1830s, but then in 1837 the economy went to hell, and the family really became poor and were really scrounging. They had to move up to uh a town north of Albany because they couldn't afford to live in Albany anymore. So Melville was taken out of school. I mean, he had very good schooling as a boy, he had a little bit of schooling in Albany, but then he went to work in his his uncle's bank, and then he worked in his brother's first, or then he became a teacher for a couple of years. So he had this sense of you know what happened. He had this comfortable environment, his family lost their money, his father died. So he I think he himself very much identified with Job as a figure of unjust suffering. I mean, why had this happened to Melville? And he finally in 1841, of course, he shipped out on the Akushnet uh to spend four years in the Pacific, and that also opened up his mind to all these other cultures, and he saw the the uh narrowness of evangelical Christianity. So I think he was key to really uh understand the book of Job based on his own life and his own um skills as a as a reader, because he was just a voracious reader and uh was very interested in religion and the Bible. I mean, he knew he knew the Bible, you know, almost by heart. And uh but he's not alone. I mean, the book of Job uh has always impressed readers as one of the most profound books of the Bible. So um you have other people commenting on on how uh Job is is is such an interesting uh document in terms of the Old Testament. You know, it's it's the wisdom tradition. So the wisdom tradition is uh is throwing uh you know, along with um uh uh Ecclesiastes and Job are really Melville's favorite books because they both were skeptical challenges to all the other parts of the Bible, which are saying that you know the world is clearly has good and evil and God is always on the good side. And both these books show that life is m, you know, good and evil are much more ambiguous than people think they are.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, I think that's great. Um, thank you so much for your time. This has been a really wonderful conversation, and I'm uh I was we were thrilled to be able to have you on for this. Sure. Uh the the book is Inscrutable Malice, uh Theodicy, Eschatology, and the Biblical Sources of Moby Dick. Um, and is there anything you wanted to uh share with our audience or uh uh plug our audience into?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, well, you know, I published this book, but I've also published about 10 other articles on Moby Dick. Um I have a new article coming out in a collection uh coming out next year on Ahab's uh Phantom Limb syndrome, you know, the medical condition of phantom limb, where you feel, feel neurologically, you feel like your limb is still there, and I'm uh, you know, making an argument about that. Um I'm usually uh in the midst of working on one thing or another related to Melville. You know, you can find me if you if you're an academic, you can find me on JSTOR and uh uh Project Muse um in those databases, my articles.
SPEAKER_02Wonderful. Well, thank you again so much, uh Dr. Jonathan Cook.
SPEAKER_00You've been listening to the Pequot Pod with Tristan Bavel Marquise, Meg Fanscher, and Johnny Wiles. Our music is by Lost in the Loop with sound engineering by Lauren Aiton. The show's artwork is by Delaney Garrett, and Tristan is on the Sits. We want to say a big thank you to all of our supporters on Patreon. You can join them over at patreon.com forward slash Pequab Pub for bonus content and for opportunities to help us keep the show running in ship-shaped condition. Ratings and reviews also really help us out, so if you enjoy the show, please do express your thoughts and metaphysical yearnings in the review section wherever you're listening to the show. Tell your friends, tell your foes, tell the white whale on whom you're monomaniacally urged to be revenged. It all helps. Thanks for listening, and until next time, call us the Pequine Party.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Age of Napoleon Podcast
Everett Rummage