PequodPod
The podcast on the wonder-world of Herman Melville. We're currently reading Moby-Dick and talking about each chapter. We also enjoy and discuss Melville's other works such as Typee, Omoo, Mardi, Redburn, Whitejacket, Pierre, Bartleby, Benito Cereno, The Confidence-Man, Billy Budd, and more!
Support the show: www.patreon.com/PequodPod
PequodPod
Episode 10: The Sermon
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Welcome to PequodPod! The podcast on the wonder-world of Herman Melville.
This is a big one. Father Mapple is bringing down the house at the Whaleman's Chapel. We talk Jonah and Paul, Chronometricals and Horologicals, swinging lamps and more!
If you enjoy the show, please consider helping defray the costs of making the show by joining us on Patreon at patreon.com/PequodPod
Please also consider telling a friend about the show. Word of mouth is the best way to spread the word about PequodPod, and it helps us tremendously.
N.B. Tristan was holding his copy of Moby-Dick a little too close to his face at times, which is why he sometimes sounds a little muffled while quoting things.
But oh shipmates, on the starboard hand of every woe there is a sure delight. And higher the top of that delight than the bottom of the woe is deep. Is not the main truck higher than the Kelsana's low? Delight is to him a far, far upward and inward delight, who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth ever stands forth his own inexorable self. Delight is to him whose strong arms yet support him when the ship of this base, treacherous world is gone down beneath him. Delight is to him who gives no quarter in the truth and kills, burns, destroys all sin, though we pluck it out from under the robes of senators and judges. Delight to God, delight is to him who acknowledges no love, our Lord, but the Lord is God, and is only a patriot to heaven. Delight is to him from all the waves of the pillows of the seas of the boisterous mob, can ever shake from the shore keel of the ages. An eternal delight and deliciousness will be his, coming to lay him down and stay with his final breath. O Father, chiefly known to me by thy rod, immortal or immortal, here I die. I have striven to be thine more than to be this world's or mine own. Yet this is nothing. I leave eternity to thee, for what is man that he should live out the lifetime of his god. Our first like confirmed like pequad.
SPEAKER_02Our first dream.
SPEAKER_04That we know of. True.
SPEAKER_02Yeah first scientifically noted dream.
SPEAKER_04But anyway, it's kind of fun. It's it's kind of interesting, like having people that like are fans of a thing you do. Um, I don't know. Uh maybe Johnny's experiences before.
SPEAKER_02Johnny, have you been dreamt of before in your maybe as an actor? Like in, you know.
SPEAKER_00Not that I know of. Um, I'm I I'm completely open to that happening. Um it's it's not it's not at all the same thing, but sometimes we do get people, you know, after obviously after the show coming up and sort of talking to us. And sometimes that's really nice. Sometimes when you've had a really tough crowd, you almost sort of don't want them to come and say anything. You can't come and say a really, really tough audience for whom you do not necessarily hold the greatest affection, and then people come up to you and say, Oh, that was really good. Well, you could have expressed that a little bit more during the show rather than just coming and telling me now.
SPEAKER_02Yes, where was that energy before?
SPEAKER_00Precisely, you've just sat through in in stony silence for two hours, and now you, one person, are coming up and telling specifically me. But anyway, yeah, I don't know that I've been dressed up. I can't think why I would be. Certainly not in the not in Malvolio's yellow stockings. I think if if I appear in in the in any sort of dream, it's a nightmare for anybody.
SPEAKER_02A portent of things to come.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_04Um, that's interesting. Uh uh, Johnny, like uh like your experience probably is an interesting one, like doing a podcast, but then also being like an actor for like live performances, because they they must be like such different things. Like one of the things that's like uh odd and can be difficult, like as like the the creator of a podcast, is like you you put it out there and there's not like instant feedback in like any kind of real way, or like you know, you like you don't like uh unless you kind of seek out your audience or they like leave reviews or something or like contact you. Um there's no kind of like real time did that land, or like you know, the you you're you're kind of like uh being listened to almost from like kind of within a black box or something. Like uh, you know.
SPEAKER_00I think that's true. Although I think my I haven't really analyzed my approach to this podcast very much, um, and maybe I should, but I think my approach is broadly similar to how I would approach certainly my individual participation in a show, which is create the performance or create the thing as the thing you would want to experience. Um, and I feel as if we the three of us have the kinds of conversations that we would like to have, and and I I like to think that I kind of do that that uh on stage as well to a point, although of course there are differences. Um and so j just because feedback on the on the podcast is potati uh is is slightly more delayed, whereas obviously doing a Shakespearean comedy, you hope that you might get a little bit of kind of incident reaction in certain moments. Um I sort of think my approach or the way the way that I think about how these things will be received are actually fairly similar.
SPEAKER_04No, that's interesting. That's cool. Yeah. Um Meg, do you have what's your experience of uh the podcasting, I guess?
SPEAKER_02Or like um podcasting, I don't know. Uh I don't know a lot of people who respond to me personally about it. Um, and I'm not an actor, um, but I do teach in person, which feels like I put on a Broadway play eight or nine times a week. And sometimes it lands and sometimes not. So, you know, sometimes the energy you get back from a group, you're like, I am I am hot today, you know, I'm I'm really killing it. And sometimes it all it feels like a flop. But um, that's part of what you sign up for in that kind of like live performance um model. And there are joys from that and there are pains from that um that uh can't really be replicated. Um but uh until you get the uh student reviews at the end of the year.
SPEAKER_04Oh yeah.
SPEAKER_00Oh gosh, that's really delayed feedback.
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_00There's a there's waiting for comments to appear in the, you know, in on on YouTube or on, you know, on Spotify or whatever. And then there's okay, well, I've got to wait eight months to hear what people actually thought of this. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um, I did so when I was a grad student doing my masters, I did get to teach a couple independent classes, which was cool. I didn't I didn't feel like the most effective teacher, and I did make sure to bring in uh donuts on uh the day that they had to do the the the teacher evaluation.
SPEAKER_00That's how you get the good feedback. Oh yes.
SPEAKER_01Feedback. Hi, this is Jenny from Portland, Oregon, and welcome to Pequad Pod, the podcast on the Wonder World of Herman Melville. I'd like to give a special shout out to our listeners and the members of the Call Me Herman Book Club with members in Portland, Seattle, Massachusetts, and North Carolina.
SPEAKER_04All right. Um, so I don't need to do the welcome to Pequad Pod. You don't. I don't. So if you you just heard uh one of our lovely uh Ahab level patrons, uh so if you don't know, uh you too could help make this show uh more sustainable and more possible um by joining our Patreon. But it's it's really fun to get to talk to our patrons and uh people who enjoy the show. It makes this like uh a much more rewarding process, like having those interactions, having people that like uh really enjoy the show, having people who think that we do this in one take uh because apparently I do a good job editing. Uh it's very fun.
SPEAKER_00But we are by no means as eloquent as Tristan makes us sound, we assure you.
SPEAKER_02That's showbiz, baby.
SPEAKER_04Oh, yes. Anyway, uh today we've got a very interesting episode, uh, one that I've been excited for, I think, since we started the show. Um, probably like I think this is the chapter I've been most excited about since starting, because it's like one of the earlier ones that was like kind of jumps out of you as like a fun one. But today we're talking about the sermon. Um and yeah, I'm gonna shoot it over to you, Meg, if you want to give us one of your uh patented uh Meg Fancher synopses.
SPEAKER_02I I would be delighted. This, as with many times, uh the chapter is more complex than the summary makes it so, although, of course, that's the point of the summary, but um we'll we'll be hitting a lot, uh a lot going on here. In the sermon, um, Father Mapple, whom we met last time, preaches the story of Jonah and the whale. He says at the outset something interesting, which is that the lesson of the story is two-stranded, that there's a message for everyone as sinners, and then there's another message for him as what he calls a pilot of the living God, which is to say that he's the pastor. Pilot here, I think um nautically, meaning that the smaller boat that guides the bigger ship out of the harbor. Um, don't fact check me on that. Just let me just let me say that that's what that means. His interpretation, he tells the story, we get the long sermon. His interpretation at the end ends by him saying that a person should find um joy and fulfillment in living not for the world or even for yourself, but for God. He says, I have striven to be thine more than to be this world or mine own. And then the chapter ends as he he delivers a benediction and the worshipers depart. So I wonder if maybe this is a chapter completely without Ishmael in it as a presence. He presumably the reader would not forget, coming off of the previous chapter, you know, that he's obviously there, but he does not give us any commentary. 98% of the chapter is a direct quotation from the preacher.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I like that a lot. That's an interesting observation, Meg. Yeah, like we don't get like Ishmael's presence so much. We do get like a very embodied language. You know, it's both like the the words of the sermon, but then also um Father Maple, like kind of what he's doing physically and like uh his like physical reactions to like sort of channeling. Uh like uh to me, like uh there's like a channeling aspect to um delivering the sermon where like he he has like these interesting, like kind of bodily reactions to different parts of it.
SPEAKER_02Um yeah, yeah, but there's no first person. And even at the end, um Ishmael does not technically include himself in the people leaving. It says till all the people had departed, not till we had departed. So it's just an interesting um sort of narrative choice on Melville's part to write it as if Ishmael is um absenting himself as storyteller for this chapter, which may or may not be something we need to look at super closely, but I think it is the first time, but not the last.
SPEAKER_04Oh, certainly not the last time. Yeah, no, I I like that uh observation about like the very end of it. We also get um kind of similarly, like the the nearly all joined in singing this hymn, and that nearly all like jumped out to me. I don't know if uh you y'all also have to.
SPEAKER_02You know Quequak was like scrolling.
unknownNot necessarily.
SPEAKER_04Do we think Ishmael's singing this too? The hymn, or it is is uh Ishmael silent? Is he in this all or is he uh the exception to the all that uh results in this nearly all?
SPEAKER_00My instinct is to say that at this stage in the narrative he's still something of a sheep. And so he's more likely to go with the many rather than the few. But I think the more daring in uh interpretation is to say that even at this early stage he's potentially not. It's really, really interesting to me that this chapter contains far and away the most speech that we've had so far. That's both proportionately to narrated prose, but also just in terms of sheer quantity. It it it really upsets in many ways uh the key of oratory that we're going to have going on really from this point onwards in the text. It primes our ears for the rhetoric of Ahab, uh potentially also to other characters uh like Starbuck and kind of competing modes and forms of oratory as well. This becomes for me a really, really significant touchstone for all of those things, while also being a really fascinating uh piece of text in its own right. Something else that I find particularly interesting or and it chimes with other conversations that we've had in the past in terms of how Melville makes use of his sources. Uh the bulk of this chapter really is something it is um is a sermon which has as its foundation the the book of Jonah. But I'm very, very interested in what Melville chooses to add, what he chooses to leave out, and what does he change about this narrative.
SPEAKER_04Father Mapple Rose in a mild voice of unassuming authority ordered the scattered people to condense, which I think is like such an interesting first sentence. Like the this idea of a uh mild voice of unassuming authority ordering people. And then, like, specifically, I think it's like interesting, uh, it's the scattered people to condense, which like already has like in in this uh first sentence like biblical uh overtones, right? So uh the idea like uh of a diaspora, right? So like you know, really the the Old Testament is so important to, or like the Hebrew Bible is so important to Moby Dick, and like you know, the kind of the crux, I would argue, of like uh the the Hebrew Bible is explaining uh exile and diaspora and being like cast out uh and being a castaway. And we already have this idea like right in the beginning of the sense, and in a way that's you know doesn't beat you over the head, but like uh kind of mirrors this idea of like this this voice of God, which is this more mild voice of unassuming authority, but still orders people to condense into one, is uh I think an interesting way to start things off.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, certainly. And this is also, and we touched on this in our last episode, I think, Father Maple as a counterpoint to several different characters, in part uh Ishmael, but certainly also to Ahab. And that mild voice of unassuming authority is in many ways everything that Ahab isn't, right? His is anything other than a mild voice or you know, any any any kind of mild form of authority.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's interesting. I'm thinking like chronologically, who do we have to compare him to yet as like a speaker, like as an out loud speaker? We don't have a lot of people. I don't think a lot of people have like set forth about anything. You know what I mean? Did the landlord talk a lot? Yeah, he's he's I think he's been our only like storyteller. Because you remember the guys at the inn didn't talk during breakfast. There wasn't conversation in the church when Ishmael gets there. He hasn't really had like a conversation with Queekweg. Like we know we're going to get some massive oratory coming down the pike, but like we haven't heard it yet. So this is really our first big um one. It's a really a monologue, right? Because the other people are staying quiet. Um and we'll get some again, we'll get some haunting, absolutely haunting ones that are coming. But um, I wonder if it's it's interesting that this is gonna be the one that we will compare the others back to. Right now we're thinking the other way because we've like read the book and we're like, Ahab, he's gonna be so different, but we haven't really met him yet. So it's rather that when we hit Ahab, we're gonna compare him back to the quiet, unassuming um Father Mapple at his fake ship. Definitely seemingly um without a lot, having to do a lot of like, well, I was I say not without a lot of theater, but there is a lot of theater, it's it's all theater, but without too much like violence or I don't know, like hand-wringing. Yeah, he gets everyone to listen to him. And that has to do with, you know, he's the preacher at a church, then that that's his job, and people expect that. Um, but still he's gonna be an interesting, he really is sort of our our ground zero, and everything later is gonna reflect back on that as a critique or like a confirmation as is this a good kind of speaker? Is this the best way to speak? Is this the way you want to speak when this is the message? And how that will kind of get like corrupted later on.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. It keys our ear in, doesn't it, into this kind of this mode of speech so that we can identify yeah, the the photo-negative versions of it when we hear them.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, a a counterpoint I would make is that I think like you could also argue that in a way Ishmael is like a has a similar sort of role. And we can compare Father Maple to Ishmael. I mean, like, so like you're starting with loomings, right? We we get like uh we get this delivered to us almost like it was uh like uh uh we're in the town pose story, right? Or like you know, we're we're we're sipping our red wine or whatever it is, or uh uh in Lima or something in uh Ishmael's like telling us, you know, he starts with like call me Ishmael. He he starts this like as like kind of a as like a verbal kind of thing, right? That like like it's some kind of story he's rehearsing to us or telling to us verbally. And like one of the big contrasts between Ishmael and Maple here is Ishmael is always ambiguous or vague or like kind of unwilling to like fully commit to like one thing or like one idea, or like really have like faith in anything that he's putting forward. He's kind of like always questioning versus Father Maple's going to be absolutely secure in his faith. Yeah. So he paused a little, then kneeling in the pulpit's bows, folded his large brown hands across his chest, uplifted his closed eyes, and offered a prayer so deeply devout that he seemed kneeling and praying at the bottom of the sea. That last bit, like uh, you know, kind of foreshadowing what we'll get later in this chapter with uh Jonah himself. But like I think it's uh interesting that he's given specifically brown hands, which to me is interesting, like in the kind of ideology that Ishmael's setting forth about complexion and being on the sea and like complexion, like being like you know, that brownness being something that goes away when you become a landed person.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and yet what he's actually being the the the extension of that image is actually he seems some somebody who's actually not on land in this moment. He seems like somebody talking from the bottom of the sea. So there's a sense there's something about his demeanour that that implies that actually he has in no way left the ocean behind in it, well, at least he hasn't done that entirely, and that somehow that persists, and maybe that's actually reflected still in his physical appearance.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, like uh he hasn't like you know, he hasn't bleached from uh tearing on land in the way that we get like from the other sailors. He still has the brown hands, even though we're led to the belief that he's like kind of given up the seafaring life to be like to take this calling. He's like sort of uh permanently uh imbued with this uh tanned sailorly quality, like uh irrespective of like this tearing. So he basically he is like almost like he's not tearing, right? As opposed to these other sailors who are just tearing ashore. He's got like this, you know, he's not tearing, he's got this like kind of new sort of mission, a new sort of drive in this like spiritual rebirth. And so like he can't bleach like the other ones do, or like that would be like kind of uh would go against the holiness of his calling in a in an interesting way.
SPEAKER_00It's become in some way a kind of an integral part of his being, and it's become a permanent part of that being. So he's not his life at sea has become part and parcel of his retirement, if that's what we want to call it, or his kind of career late-stage career change back onto the land, but into a land-based environment that, as we've had ample cause to discuss, is also so bound up uh physically in terms of its architecture and design, but also thematically and functionally with the sea.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I love that. Um, so we get this like uh opening hymn that every nearly everybody, nearly all joined in singing. Do we have any thoughts on this? So it's uh it's gonna come from Psalm 18, um, and it's very nautical. We got a whale in it.
SPEAKER_02I'm gonna be honest with you. Whenever I read a book and the narrative stops and I get like a song or a poem, my eye usually skips over it. Um, I think at some point I have read this, but I don't usually I think usually it's optional, and I wish writers um didn't do it. And that's my note for Herman Melville. Cut the song. Um, but yeah, it's you know, it's nautical. There you got a maw of hell in there, that's nice. Um, you give the gory the glory to God. That's a psalm. Not as John Mullaney says, not a song, but a psalm.
SPEAKER_00I think I'm a bit more sympathetic to this kind of thing than Meg. I I s I get the same experience certainly when reading Tolkien. Um I don't need to wade through another song about plates. Um, I don't think. Uh having said that, it may well be, though I'll really happily be corrected, um, the first instance of actually separating out different types of cetacean into their distinct categories. So we get the whale as a as a kind of quite generic uh category, but then we get in that uh fourth fourth verse with speedy flu to my relief as on a radiant dolphin born. So it's interesting actually this is this is a first um or at least a very early instance of actually categ starting to categorize the creatures that this this text revolves around.
SPEAKER_02Yes, is this the first time we really hit heavily the idea of fish and whale being interchangeable?
SPEAKER_00Quite well, possibly is. That's also something that the book of Jonah does. I won't swear to its being the first time. Certainly we get it in the extracts.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but this is the first one where. it's like for protracted chapter, we're like, should we not be calling it a whale? Because that's what it is. So now it's like now we have to pay attention to it because it is actually um notable.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, no, that's interesting. So it's very easy, fortunately, for this one to like pull up uh biblical citations because uh Jonah is literally like two pages long. Uh we could easily read the whole thing and insert it in here. I'm not gonna do that right now, but it it does make it easy. And I encourage people to read it because I think it's uh it's very interesting to see like how Melville through Father Maple kind of expands upon and fleshes out the story of Jonah and specifically only like half the story of Jonah, which I think uh you alluded to as well. This is really about chapters one and two of the book of Jonah, uh which I think are the parts that most people think about um like when they think about the story of Jonah. But chapters three and four are also very interesting. We we we might discuss them. But specifically to your point Meg um in at least the King James version of the Bible which I I believe this is also I can if we really need to I can uh go up over there and get my uh innerlinear Bible which has the the Hebrew for us but it's a great fish to swallow up Jonah so at least in the text that Melva would have had specifically it's a great fish uh and it's referred to as a fish but so it's more that it is a fish and we have put whale on it more can contemporarily like when did it become a whale?
SPEAKER_02In my mind it's a whale and we it's wrong to call it a fish. Is it actually the other way around and like through translations we've called it whale because whales are bigger or am I just thinking of Pinocchio it's a really good question and one that I wish I had the answer to. I don't know which what it is.
SPEAKER_04Um so yeah so I think like uh from like a biblical perspective whales I'm fairly certain are considered within the category of fishes or like you know kind of like the kind of due to their being in the same domain basically and so if you're like thinking about this as a you know a person trying to do uh interpreting Jonah like kind of literally which it's kind of a fraught thing because Jonah is like a very weird four chapters of a book of the Bible and like kind of I would say like kind of intentionally satirical as well. Interesting. Kind of like uh Jonah in a way is kind of like this anti-prophet and like uh I I a lot of people argue that like kind of the point of the book of Jonah is kind of to make fun of like the other prophets that are in the Bible. Interesting. But yeah uh I I I guess what I would say is like okay it needs to be some kind of of fish. Whales are included in the category of fish and it has to be something that's big enough to hold a human being in its mouth or belly.
SPEAKER_02Are whales kosher?
SPEAKER_00Are whales kosher if they're fish not all fish are kosher I believe we're gonna put a pin in this because I'm gonna get down to this yeah how we define fish is you know there's there's famously no such thing as a fish really they don't have trotters scales.
SPEAKER_04They don't have scales now that's an interesting question.
SPEAKER_02I'll find so okay we'll we'll track this down. But in any case it's a big thing somewhere in a storyteller where a kid would be like yeah a person could fit in the belly of that thing.
SPEAKER_00So for now we'll just say it's fish but I think yeah I think yeah I guess it is the other way around we'll figure this out as um we're starting to kind of get into the meat of Mapple's sermon on Jonah and while we're talking about well okay what does Melville adapt what does he add what does he take away what does he change um I'm really really fascinated by the very very start of the of the sermon proper where we get Mappel saying beloved shipmates clinch the last verse of the first chapter of Jonah and God had prepared a great fish to swallow up Jonah. Now does it matter and follow-up question are we interested in the fact that this is a misquote and not only is it a misquote we get the correct quotation at the beginning of the extract which interesting in the extract we get now the Lord had prepared a great fish to swallow up Jonah and that is the King James version. So what do we make of the fact that the first citation from Jonah that Mapple gives is a misquote. Yeah and he's got the book right in front of him on the shaky exactly that's the other really fun I mean it's pretty similar. It it is really really similar but why would Melville insert what if we're being pedantic about it the wrong thing when he's quotes it correctly true maybe this is the second extract.
SPEAKER_02Yeah maybe it's uh maybe uh we're we're signaling that he's kind of more of like a man of the people to say it might be like a little more colloquially and God had prepared versus now the Lord had prepared it has the double quotes on mind to say that he is quoting rather than um saying it off the top of his head maybe his Bible maybe this is a what am I trying to say this is a signal that his Bible is not an official Bible perhaps which would then have a sort of cascading effect of um more like hominess.
SPEAKER_04Yeah there's a lot of a uh this is like a you know a period of great like kind of religious interest and fervor. So yeah we could have you know it could be a different Bible it could be to like it could be like an intentional sort of way of like uh destabilizing us in this textual tradition which maybe is the interpretation you're going for Johnny.
SPEAKER_00I'm certainly excited by that as an idea. That is exciting. Especially in terms of how Melville is kind of engaging with and to some measure destabilizing our relationship with the veracity of other texts and kind of the authority of other texts. Of course the but the Bible is is a sort of is a case unto itself of course but or is it in Melville's hands? I don't know. That's another another very much open question. We've been talking about the fact that we're still very much in the in the phase of the text where Melville as opposed to Ishmael is kind of instructing us in how this text is to be interpreted and here we have two different versions of the same quotation and I suppose implicit in in in the two different quotations is okay so what's the difference between now and what's the difference between and what's the difference between now and and and now and then God versus Lord as well.
SPEAKER_04That's kind of like the the big one absolutely because those are different Hebrew words. Very much so what do you all find interesting about the story of Jonah I guess we haven't like really talked about the story of Jonah very much so far. It might be useful uh in brief it's already a very brief as uh Mapula attests to but like really we're specifically only talking about the first two chapters of Jonah um the first of which like kind of the the central point of which is God calls on Jonah to go to Nineveh to like uh preach there about like kind of the iniquity of what they're doing there and like kind of call on them to repent. But this is very very frightening to Jonah so he seeks to flee to the opposite end of the the earth right in respect to where like Nineveh is Father Mapple thinks is Cadiz. Yeah yeah what's what's interesting about like thinking about Jonah as a whole though uh and we only get like the the first two chapters here is like in uh chapter three like when he actually like eventually you know he's so if if you don't know he he takes a ship that the the sea rebels he's cast into the ocean gets swallowed by the whale um and then from there like you know he he repents in the the the belly of the the whale and he's vomited out um and is able to go and do his mission. And what's interesting to me is like uh what happens after that is uh like the Ninevite's like kind of immediately like oh yeah you're right and it's like the easiest thing in the world to like kind of convert them all.
SPEAKER_00The thing that he's going to do it seems to me sort of less significant is given less weight than the process of how that thing ends up happening.
SPEAKER_04Yeah like once he actually does it it's like the easy like no prophet has had like an easier time converting people like in the whole Bible. It's completely simple like and even like the animals are like fasting and wearing sackcloth because like they're so convinced. And so it's like the like God knows this is going to be the easiest thing in the world for Jana. And what's interesting about this sermon is like uh Father Michael kind of brackets out like the rest of Jana. We're really only caring about the first two chapters and specifically like this disobedience and then turning back to God and kind of like the the the dialectical process there. Like uh and it's like kind of through like disobedience and then like you know the the the suffering that occurs that one finds God again. Like even in the belly of the whale I think is an interesting point.
SPEAKER_00Well yeah and Maple seems to be playing up the importance of the cetacean body as part of that process.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Right and and and it's it's there's very distinctive kind of cetacean vocabulary threaded through the his entire account of as you say Tristan the first two the first two chapters even for even right from the uh right from the top yet what depth of the soul does Jonah's deep sea line sound and that verb sound comes up a couple of times in that opening passage to mean to kind of to to to plumb the depths of a of a thing. I mean Herschel Parker's notes say that oh yeah a a sound in this context a weighted rope dropped overboard to measure the depth of the sea bottom but that's also the verb given still today but also in Moby Dick for when a whale goes down towards the bottom of the ocean. And so it's interesting that it both in terms of the content of the biblical source but also in terms of the specific vocabulary that he gives to Maple the whale as a vehicle for the process and for the and for this narrative within narrative is absolutely paramount.
SPEAKER_02Cool. Cool the the thing that's most interesting to me about Mapple's talking about this is this the second part of this sort of um this dual lesson he says that the story has for us, which is the part where he's saying is um the part that falls on me. Later on in sort of the second to last page of um the chapter he talks about God has but has laid but one hand upon you, both his hands press upon me. He says I would rather be in your seat looking up at someone else telling me what the story is about but it has to be me. And he compares himself to Jonah how being an anointed pilot prophet or speaker of true things and bidden by the Lord to sound those unwelcome truths in the ears of the wicked people et cetera he was a Jonah was appalled by his mission. So for me I the thing that most it interests me about this chapter is what Melville seems to be saying about the burden of being a storyteller or the great great burden it is to be an interpreter. So the Father Mapple is saying you know obviously this can teach us about sin, but maybe that's only obvious because you've been told that that's what the story is about so many times by people like me. And there's a huge burden on my shoulders to tell you what an allegory is about. And if I get that wrong are the consequences your soul or your relationship with your God that's huge. And maybe that was what Jonah was was appalled by to use the word in that quote he said that's maybe it wasn't necessarily oh I have to schlep out there or like I don't know anybody out there like whatever it was about like I don't want to do the job of can of of preaching is so is is massive on like a person's like psyche. So this um part where you know he's saying what God asks of us is really hard. So even if the thrust of the story is how much suffers um and then um finds uh what's that great not clamorous for pardon but grateful for punishment he comes around um but still the thing that weighed on him was maybe Melville is saying the thing that really weighed on this um on this character is the huge responsibility and perhaps the grave consequences of misinterpretation.
SPEAKER_00That's great.
SPEAKER_04I really like that in my mind there's kind of like uh uh three like aspects that are like kind of key from like a uh biblical perspective so we've got so Jonah's are like kind of a our main point so uh father maple is telling the story of Jonah like retelling it and we should get to some of the uh the beautiful language that's used and some of the characters that kind of like get the chance to speak um in ways that they don't in the source material. I find the the captain like very interesting. Yeah he's great um which is like uh you know like uh embellished from the original or like kind of uh in fleshed out from the original uh biblical story uh also very critical is uh Paul and specifically like we get the the um in at towards the end the citation of uh you know like as the uh the great pilot Paul has it uh while preaching to others is himself a castaway which is specifically uh a call back to first corinthians uh nine uh 27 um but i keep under my body and bring it into into subjection lest that by any means when I have preached to others I myself should be a castaway uh and like I think we've got like kind of these three uh levels here maybe more than three levels we've got Mapple who's like uh taking into mind the importance and role of being a spiritual leader and he's calling to mind both Jonah and Paul as like relevant figures uh and relevant kind of role models or like counter role models and really like Jonah you know like it it's it's such an interesting text because you get this like deep and profound like uh you know repentance while in the belly of the whale but if we go to like chapters three and four there's not like a a like Jonah doesn't continue like he hasn't really learned anything which is kind of interesting I think um you know he's like he's kind of mad at that the the Nineveh were so easy to convert he was looking forward to the the destruction of Nineveh right he thought okay I'm gonna go here and preach against them and then God's wrath's gonna come and they're not gonna listen to me right they're not gonna listen to me so the God's going to destroy Nineveh. But then he doesn't he's successful. It's a weird aspect of Jonah and I think like maybe it's uh relevant to Father Maple or thinking about like being a spiritual leader in general when you're like you know telling people they need to convert uh lest you like burn in hell or whatever. How many of these people like are really kind of fantasizing about you not converting and then like subsequently like having this horrible thing happen to you? I think it's a tension there like kind of throughout like both the like uh uh Hebrew and like also Christian traditions it's like there's uh people seem more interested in the the the damnation hell and torment part for one's enemies. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yes and to to what degree does the conversion successful process of conversion actually depend on some people not converting and therefore being able to say well those people are actually they're they're they're going downstairs. Right other otherwise if if it were as easy as it is at the end of the journal narrative in a hundred percent of cases actually in in some way sort of spreading the good word and actually converting more willing people actually becomes prop possibly becomes more complicated.
SPEAKER_04I don't know it's not something I've ever dabbled in but yeah um if I'm remembering correctly one of the early church fathers I think it's origin. I believe it's origin. Yeah fact check me if you want um it used to be like a uh canon that everybody in the end would be converted including the devil um that that used to be it's an uphill battle but okay yeah yeah because then if if if that's the case then what's the point in leading a moral Christian life here on earth if we're all going if we're all eventually going to be saved anyway.
SPEAKER_02Wasting time. Yeah thinking about there eating whales whether they're kosher or not.
SPEAKER_04Yeah but it used to be like a pretty like established belief in Christianity that there was reincarnation and that God's merciful so he gives people like an infinite number of lives to try and be saved to like to to turn to to God. And like uh that's why eventually everybody will be saved in like however many lives it takes including the devil. But that has not that that's no longer a canon. Interesting so uh Johnny you like this captain. Why don't you tell us about this captain?
SPEAKER_00I do I like this captain very much uh he gets a great deal more airtime than in in Maple's sermon than he does in uh in in the book of Jonah. Um I'm really really fascinated by the amount that he perceives um and the fact that he's got Jonah's number really before Jonah has even set foot on the ship. Um let me find this. Jonah's captain prepares to test the length of Jonah's purse ere he judge him openly. He charges him thrice the usual sum and it's assented to then the captain knows that Jonah is a fugitive but at the same time resolves to help a flight that paves its rear with gold. Now correct me if I'm wrong this does not come up at least in this this no mention of this is made in the at least in the King James uh yeah the only thing we get is what is quoted here um by Maple like he cites that he paid the fare thereof which is like basically kind of where he's getting like his you know cinematic version. Yeah yeah but it's a really fascinating embellishment here um the the captain also does uh an amount of interpretation for us as well um he makes judgments based on Jonah's complexion um point out my stateroom sir says Jonah now I'm travel weary I need sleep thou looks like it says the captain there's thy room it's the the the the captain himself is engaged in an active interpretation in this moment and it also seems to me I'll I'll and I'll throw this idea out there um because I I I it may be that um it's not one that you two agree with but I almost get a sense that the captain in Maple's sermon has read the book of Jonah. A weird paradox right but um but it but it it it's but not like Ishmael already knows how his story ends. Exactly um a a really uh an analogue that that sprung to mind as I was looking at this is um for example the the fifth canto of Dante's Inferno the the uh the canto of Francesca da Rimini um who is slain by her husband uh when she is caught in Delctia flagrante with her lover uh Paolo um and she talks a great deal to Dante about the nature of love and how it is quickly kindled in a in a certain kind of lover's heart and it becomes quite clear that she's read Dante's early work and he's almost having Francesca speak Dante's own words back to him. Yeah or or or Titus Andronicus which is a a really early Shakespeare play where um which is very closely or it's at least very very sort of heavily underpinned by um uh certain stories in Ovid's Metamorphoses and then one of the characters two two characters have actually been uh have actually know the text of Ovid's Metamorphoses and the text actually appears as a prop on stage at one point in the play. There's a really interesting I'm fascinated by sort of moments when characters seem to be aware of the story that they're in.
SPEAKER_02That is so I love that. Yeah that's so haunting that's really good. That's really good.
SPEAKER_00Yeah and I and the captain seemed seems to me to be doing a little bit of that which which just really I don't know it it pushes all of my sort of literary enjoyment buttons um which is why I wanted him to get a bit of airtime.
SPEAKER_04Yeah I I I kind of get like a Peter Coffin also energy from the captain. Certainly oh yeah like for both of these characters like the the the capitalistic instinct is like the foremost one.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_04One thing I do think is interesting as like kind of a callback to one of our earlier chapters is the contrast between Jonah here and Ishmael in Loomings. When Looming when Ishmael's talking about like uh all the difference in the world between like you know paying and being paid and that he never uh pays to sail. Absolutely uh versus Jonah paying uh thrice the normal charge.
SPEAKER_00That's a lovely spot um a little way up uh uh above that passage uh notice how Jonah prepares to go on the voyage how plainly he's a fugitive no baggage not a hat box valise or carpet bag uh and they're and of course chapter two is sort of well built around this as we've said before drastic under preparation to go on a whaling voyage but at least he takes something and uh and and it's one of the things that Jonah is listed as pointedly not taking no carpet bag no nothing.
SPEAKER_02It marks him as suspicious.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_02I like this part when they they cast lots and I know I'm kind of skipping around but I I just like the language of it um they fall to casting lots to see who the the thing the lot is Jonah's that discovered then how furiously they mob him with their questions. What is thine occupation? Whence comest thou thy country what people I like both the dialect he has them have which I think is father Maple's dialect to use that sort of Quakerish um I'm not using that word inappropriately but sort of like the thines and the thou's sounds old fashioned even to maybe Ishmael um but also sort of has it makes it sound more more serious more biblical more grave certainly more biblical yeah where whence comest thou uh what people do you have and Jonah not having an answer to these that is um not a lie at least strips him of almost all the identity whereas before all he can say is then loop back around and say what he hopes will get him out of trouble, which is the truth but the the thing that condemns him to a punishment he says I am a Hebrew I fear the Lord uh the Lord God of heaven like you guys have been saying um we're now deep enough into the book where we can start calling back to things. We can call back to Brown hands, we can call back to luggage, we can call back to even like these pronouns. We're deep in enough where Melville can start making connections. And now we're establishing patterns. Whereas before everything new we saw, we're like, well, that's weird. Now we're able to be like, oh, this is like that other thing. So now that's how long form storytelling works. Once you leave short of short story or like novella length, we're starting to sort of really see the lay of the land as it were. And um, we can absolutely start saying things like symbols, like luggage mean something, because this is like the fourth time we've seen it. We now know we're keeping an eye out for what kind of suitcase did this person bring because it's important, because he's told us it's important.
SPEAKER_00On the level of uh sort of uh storytelling and mechanisms of narrative, I'm really, really interested in the way that this passage that you've singled out, Meg, unfolds. I suspect this is an early, again, maybe not even the first example, of what we in the biz of literary analysis might call Historon Proteron, which is a device whereby the chronological or logical order of events are are reversed. I'm really, really fascinated by the fact that that passage opens, terrors upon terrors run shouting through his soul, in his cringing attitudes, the god fugitive is now too plainly known. In other words, at that point it it would seem everybody knows that it's that that it's him and that he is the cause of everything that's going on. But then we get the sailors mark him, and more and more certain grow their suspicions of him, and at last, fully to test the truth, by referring the whole mass to high heaven, they fall to casting lots to see for whose cause this great tempest was upon them. But hold on, they'd already ascertained it in that opening pair of sentences, and then they start doing the litmus test.
SPEAKER_02Well, that's his interpretation, right? The way that he's telling the story makes it seem like they already know what's going on.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Well, yeah, absolutely. The narrative logic there to my mind is slightly flawed.
SPEAKER_04And to ex yeah, to extend that further, um, it's only in it's after they cast the lots that they still decide to do whatever they can before throwing them overboard to save the ship. Yeah. And so you think like it's actually like kind of the exact opposite, where like they're doing everything they can to save the ship, then they notice that this guy's like uh or they like cast the lots or whatever, like to identify this person. I think no, that's a very interesting point. Yeah. I do like that they uh even after they figure out that it's his fault that they try every other way to save the ship, uh ship. I I think that's like that that's that's still that's also in Jonah, like the the biblical book as well, which I think is like uh uh the the the sailors come off pretty well, I think. That's nice in the book of Jonah. Um even as they like uh sacrifice him.
SPEAKER_02Um yeah, eventually takes them takes them a while.
SPEAKER_04One of the things that I thought was a really interesting addition to the story is uh the the the swinging lamp.
SPEAKER_02I love the lamp, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Uh which is absolutely not present in the biblical text. Um, and it's such like kind of an elaborate idea to be kind of fleshed out in this paragraph in the sermon. So the idea is that Jonah is going to go to sleep, and I think there's also interesting language about sleep, and I I can definitely relate to Jonah, like uh thinking about okay, you know, I've had like uh some kind of night on the town, uh gotten very drunk, and like I'm sure that I did things like I uh I would be uh uh peeved about in the morning, but like the the uh the the the blackness or like the darkness or like kind of the the the lack of self in sleep is kind of like this uh uh this beautiful like thing that separates you from like those consequences the next day until they come. And then that seems to be kind of like what's happening. Uh we even get like the the the language of like uh drunken revel uh in the the this passage where like so he's on the ship, he's sleepy, goes to his stateroom, he sleeps. Uh, even in this gale, as it's becoming extremely loud, he's still sleeping. But like beforehand, we get this very odd uh paragraph about the the swinging lamp. Johnny, did you have thoughts about the swinging lamp? Or make actually you you you jumped out of the swinging lamp. What do you think of the swinging lamp?
SPEAKER_02Oh, I just think it's a as you say, a complete uh Melville um invention, um, which is to say that the Father Maple's inventing it, whether or not his audience uh knows that probably he's taking a little creative license. But if I understand it correctly, what he is literally saying is that the the lamp oscillates because it's we're on a ship, but more or less has its the way that it casts light, you know, light lamps, we're all familiar. But because the ship is also off kilter in the storm, nothing is straight. And that it is like driving Jonah crazy. I really like this detail. It feels very like Borgesian, like this. Um it's this little um sort of like magical realist detail where like um, I don't know, like the wrong slant of light gives you like a headache, and then that reminds you of like all the sins that you've committed. It it feels very like kind of primal like that um to be in, you know, the belly of the ship. The um in truth infallibly hate uh straight itself, but it made obvious the false lying levels among which it hung a couple sentences later. But that contradiction in the lamp more and more appalls him. That word appall uh is so I love that word. It feels more like the sublime, which we've talked about a couple times. Like there's something can make you angry or something can make you sad, etc. Um, and Jonah is afraid and like they're trying to, you know, they're feeling terror. But appalled has like a like a almost like a cosmic sense to it that we'll find, you know, later on um in the novel in a couple of different ways. But that word appall makes it feel like I can't even, even just think about this, um, makes my skin crawl. So something about like that light not being right seems to unsettle his soul. And this is a Melvillian thing he has put on there on top of already Jonah's actual biblical problem. So it's interesting he wants to put that dimens that extra dimension of like an evil light.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, we we we get even within the same uh chapter, uh, another time appall being used towards the end, where we've got uh woe to him who seeks to please rather than to appall rather than to give us call back to appall.
SPEAKER_02So appall is like a spiritual upset, like disgust, like with existence.
SPEAKER_04There's a there's a a part in Pierre that I feel like I'm going to call back to a million times over the course of this podcast, which is called uh uh there's this pamphlet, it's uh chronometricals and horologicals. Um and the idea is that you know, like uh basically to be uh to follow God is to to not follow like anything that makes sense at all in this world, right? And I think like the this swinging, like the this lamp, right? So um from what I understand of what's going on with the lamp is like they're still loading the bales onto the ship, so they're still at harbor, but the like the bales force the ship on like this incline. So because the lamp is like controlled by gravity, is like where it should be, like it throws off the perspective. And I think like that relates to the chronomet chronometricals and orologicals, or this idea of like spiritual truth being like uh the folly of the world, uh, and like it appalling is that like the the the light is the the the real spiritual truth and like the real like what you should be doing or like what it's actually moral um and the the walls and like the the rest of like uh the the this cabin that Jonah's in is like basically like like what makes sense actually in the world. And so like the the light being off is like kind of proof like you know a testimony against Jonah's actions, like being in this like cabin room fleeing from God, like this lamp is like uh is like the you know the the command of God saying that like this room itself is wrong, yeah. And like you know, like the the physics of this room don't make sense.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I could see this being in like a Poe short story or something. I was thinking Poe well you know, doesn't it feel that way a little bit? Yeah, similar to Century American Gothic. Yeah, that's cool.
SPEAKER_00That's really cool. Incidentally, I mean I think you you're both absolutely right to zero in on that on on the word appall and and the and the idea of what what is appalling. It's a verb that comes up several other times in the sermon, Tristan. You've already noted one of them. It then disappears for quite a while. The next time it appears is Tautology, it then appear the next time it appears after that is in the chapter, Moby Dick, chapter 41, and the next time is in The Whiteness of the Whale, chapter 42. Some heavy hitters.
SPEAKER_02So we keep this word.
SPEAKER_00Right. We pocket this word and we and we keep coming back to it because it crops up in some pretty significant places.
SPEAKER_02Wow, that's so cool. Thank you for looking that up. That's a that's a good detail.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that that's a good one. We appreciate that. Good old drastic control F, Meg.
SPEAKER_02Control F, yeah. Hold on.
SPEAKER_00No, no, no, I just I just happened to know that it was I would not put it past you to just have that in your back pocket.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I love that I can give you that impression, Meg, but no, not this time. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04I mean, you do have like this snack for memory for like lots of different uh, you know, like Shakespeare sonnets.
SPEAKER_02You should get into that. Can you memorize things?
SPEAKER_04Professionally memorize Moby Dick.
SPEAKER_00Professionally? Oh god, can I if I could memorize anything, I would to memorize Moby Dick would be amazing.
unknownOh yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Give it a go.
SPEAKER_04One last kind of like uh interesting thing about the word Apollo or like something that jumps out to me is like it has Paul, like the name in it, or like it's like right like you know, it has the same sounds there. And Paul, like being such a crucial aspect, if not like the main focus of this sermon. Definitely like referred to and also like very relevant to the sermon. And like this idea of like uh I don't think anybody like more so than Paul, is at least in like the New Testament, uh, focuses on like how insane it is to be Christian, or like how it does not make sense at all, like within like anything we like kind of get from the world. But that's kind of like the point. Like Christianity shows like kind of the folly of wisdom, or like there is this tension between anything that like would be like good for what seems like good for you in this world is like kind of the opposite of what you need with respect to Christianity, which I think you like we we get this in the sermon where uh Father Mapple says, But all things that God would have us do are hard for us to do. Remember that. If we obey God, we must disobey ourselves. And it is in disobeying ourselves wherein the hardness of obeying God consists. Um I think like that tension is important, and like it's it very important for like Christianity in general, but it's something that Melville finds very interesting. It's gonna write about a lot in Moby Dick, but then also really like I think that's like the main point of Pierre. Um, is like the the the the specifically like how irrational or like impossible it is to like actually be a Christian, or like how basically being a Christian, and you get this in the New Testament too, where Jesus is calling on people to like take up their cross and follow him. Like basically, like the the Christian in impulse and is is in a sense like a almost a suicidal impulse or like a uh like a socially suicidal impulse at the very least.
SPEAKER_00I I think that's a really interesting read, Tristan. Also, as you as you were reading those lines there from the text, it kind of almost made religious dissent sound a bit like mutiny.
SPEAKER_03Oh, interesting.
SPEAKER_00And the sense that even though it sometimes it might seem to make a certain logical sense, it behove according to maritime law, it behoves those who are working under a captain to nevertheless adhere to the rule of the captain.
SPEAKER_02Yes. Well, we're gonna talk about what God is God when we're actually out at sea soon.
SPEAKER_00Well, absolutely.
SPEAKER_02And how Ahab wants to kind of yeah, hijack that idea and everything Pip says. Yeah. So these are some important um, we don't necessarily have to totally understand it yet, but these are things, yeah, um, that we're gonna, he's gonna complicate as we move on. And that idea of like your your North Star should be beyond yourself and the world, but the tension there is that you live in the world and you are yourself. So what does that look like? We're about to see a couple successful and not so successful um examples.
SPEAKER_04So I love all the language in this, but some of the language I like especially uh we get towards the end. So, like to to summarize, right? So like uh uh Jonah gets vomited up after he has like this uh this deeply spiritual moment of like turning towards the temple. And the idea, like uh one thing I really like about Father Maple's uh sermon, we we get this line here shipmates, I do not place Jonah before you to be copied for his sin, but I do place him before you as a model for repentance. Sin not, but if you do, take heed to repent of it like Jonah. And specifically, like what like Maple, I think, like uh finds so like kind of moving about Jonah's repentance is that like it doesn't ask for forgiveness, right? Like, you know, what what Jonah's doing is he's turning towards the temple and acknowledging God, and kind of like we'll get as like a rhyme at the very end of the sermon, where we have, I have striven to be thine more than to be this world's or mine own. Yet this is nothing, I leave eternity to thee, for what is man that he should live out the lifetime of this God. And this idea of like acknowledging God as being more important than the like the individual person, or like, and like an understanding of like kind of the justice of like the whale, uh especially thinking of this as like a foreshadowing chapter, where some of the stuff we'll get like for the entire book, right? Like Jonah's ability to make peace with like death by the whale is so crucial here, and it's going to be so opposed by a uh such an important character we'll get later.
SPEAKER_00Yes, I think you're absolutely right. I I I really like that yet this is nothing, I leave eternity to thee. This sense of a surrender of the human self to God and the this idea that actually the human self is is nothing, which chimes back in with something that he had Jonah actually uh uh talk about earlier in the chapter, where in giddy anguish he's praying God for annihilation until the fit be passed. That this this chapter also kind of circulates around that idea of nothingness, that idea of annihilation.
SPEAKER_02Does that jive with the end of um the chapel? In fact, take my body, who will take it? I say it is not me.
SPEAKER_00I think it does.
SPEAKER_04I think it does. In a sense, yeah, I think so. I think so. I think it's interesting with respect to that. One of the things I find like so interesting about this uh this end of the sermon is like the way that Father Mapple deprioritizes the idea of eternal life. When eternal life is such an important part of the appeal for so many people who are Christian, right? And like that gets undercut very heavily by Mapple, who says that it's basically like not like any human's like his place to live forever. Like that's what God's supposed to do. But for Mapple, that's not the point. Like the idea of like everlasting life. Uh, we we even get like uh in one of our preceding chapters, I think the chapel, like the idea of Adam, like kind of like being in this like stasis for 6,000 years since his death, as kind of like this morbid idea, or like this like uh unpleasant idea. Um, but like I think like um like the idea of like submission or like in some way being like uh integrated with God, as opposed to like the idea of like you know, uh being your human self forever, as like uh being the more important interpretation or the more important uh aspect of eternity and of death and of like kind of the hope of God, like everlasting life not being that, or like uh being maybe like a a false interpretation.
SPEAKER_00That's interesting, especially in the context of this chapter and of a moral message being delivered by a chaplain, you know, uh a minister who was also a whaleman and so whose life has been so characterized by death. This man who has presumably seen more human mortality than the the the priest in the church up the road. And so it's interesting that that should be the angle to because I think it I th I think if I think it is. I think that's a really, really interesting read of kind of where we end up with Maple at the end of the chapter.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Unless it's like a coal mine church.
SPEAKER_00Uh well, yeah, that's true. That's true.
unknownThat's true.
SPEAKER_02If it's something like uh cabbage farmers or something, he might be safe. That might be a more cheerful place.
SPEAKER_00Much less death by cabbage, I think, on average.
SPEAKER_02I won't say totally different problems. I won't say that they don't have their problems, but they probably can find all of their bodies.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Slug management, not so much of an issue on a on a whale ship, probably.
SPEAKER_04It's a tough in uh 2026 to be eating too much cabbage, at least if you're in the United States. But uh it's maybe less of a cabbage farmer than a cabbage enjoyer problem. Um the the maybe the endus, uh, because I this is one of my favorite sections of the entire book. Um it's something that's like such an important like uh moral invocation for me. I I want to read it. This is something I normally think I'd ask uh Johnny to read it, but no, it must be it must be you, Tristan.
SPEAKER_00It must be you. Go on.
SPEAKER_04Okay. So then God spake onto the fish, and from the shuddering cold and blackness of the sea, the whale came breaching up towards the warm and pleasant sun, and all the delights of air and earth, and vomited out Jonah upon the dry land. When the word of the Lord came a second time, and Jonah, bruised and beaten, his ears like two sea shells still multitudinously murmuring of the ocean, Jonah did the Almighty's bidding. And what was that shipmates? To preach the truth to the face of falsehood, that was it. This shipmates, this is that other lesson, and woe to that pilot of the living God who slights it. Woe to him whom this world charms from gospel duty. Woe to him who seeks to pour oil upon the waters when God has brewed them into a gale. Woe to him who seeks to please rather than to appall. Woe to him whose good name is more to him than goodness. And I love that line. Woe to him who in this world courts not dishonor, woe to him who would not be true, even though to be false were salvation. Yeah, woe to him who, as the great pilot Paul has it, while preaching to others, is himself a castaway. And like this idea, especially in this day and age, especially with genocide happening in the world today and all all sorts of uh all sorts of evil perpetrated, I think that like it this is like an enduring message. And I think it's an enduring message, you know, like uh both from Obi Dick, but then also from like uh the Christian tradition as well, uh, which is that the idea, like, you know, it's so easy to like be complacent in all the evils that happen around you. And it's so easy to become, you know, like uh to enrich yourselves off of human misery. But like the call is to like kind of forsake everything uh in the name of goodness, forsake one's good name in the sake of goodness, and the forsake anything uh you know pleasant in this world for the sake of what's right, which I think is uh such an important aspect of like what we get in this sermon.
SPEAKER_00I like that very much. That's a very a very pleasing moral to extract from from the chapter and indeed from the episode. Love it.
SPEAKER_04Well, this has been fun. Um, and we will catch you uh soon for a bosom friend. Everybody needs a bosom friend. Certainly Ishmael does.
SPEAKER_02Really, yeah, really quickly, please just in our last bit of important news whales, not kosher. Uh huh. They um, according to the Torah, they do not have fins or scales, so we can't eat them as fish, and they do not have uh split hooves, nor to their cuds, so we can't eat them as mammals.
SPEAKER_04Wonderful.
SPEAKER_02So on this, our last day of Yom Kippur, it's important to note whales, take them off the list, take them out of your spread.
SPEAKER_04Good to know.
SPEAKER_02They're also exhorting me to remember that whales are a protected species and are very endangered and not to eat them for fun, even if they were kosher. But just as a, you know, as a we were wondering, and there it is.
SPEAKER_03Thank you very much for that. All right, well, see y'all next time. Bye-bye.
SPEAKER_00You've been listening to the Pequot Pot with Tristan Bavell Marquise, Meg Fanscher, and Johnny Wiles. Our music is by Lost in the Loop with sound engineering by Lauren Ayton. The show's artwork is by Delaney Garrett, and Tristan is on The Synths. We want to say a big thank you to all of our supporters on Patreon. You can join them over at patreon.com forward slash pequodpod for bonus content and for opportunities to help us keep the show running in ship-shaped condition. Ratings and reviews also really help us out, so if you enjoy the show, please do express your thoughts and metaphysical yearnings in the review section wherever you're listening to the show. Tell your friends, tell your foes, tell the white whale on whom you're monomaniacally urged to be revenged. It all helps.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Age of Napoleon Podcast
Everett Rummage